Do You Even Lift, Bruh?
Body image is a multifaceted topic, particularly within gay culture, where societal pressures and community norms often intertwine. One of the most visible manifestations of this is gym culture, which holds a unique place in the LGBTQ+ community. For many gay men, the gym is more than a space for fitness—it’s a social hub, a coping mechanism, and, at times, a source of validation.
However, this environment also carries a shadow side, fostering insecurities and exacerbating mental health struggles tied to body image ideals. By exploring this complex intersection, we can begin to unpack the ways gym culture shapes self-perception and impacts the emotional well-being of gay men.
The Evolution of Weightlifting and Gym Culture
According to BarBend, the official media partner of USA Weightlifting, weightlifting and gym culture have a rich history rooted in ancient civilizations. From India and Persia to Greece and Rome, physical fitness was deeply intertwined with daily life and societal values. The Greek word “gymnasium” reflects its origins, combining gumnazo (to exercise) and gumnos (loincloth or naked), as gymnasiums in ancient Athens were multifunctional spaces for exercise, education, and leisure. These facilities inspired similar venues in Roman culture, which adopted both private gymnasiums for elites and military barracks for soldiers.
After the decline of Greco-Roman ideals during Europe’s Dark Ages, gym culture saw a revival in the Renaissance with the publication of De Arte Gymnastica by Girolamo Mercuriale in 1569. The 18th century further emphasized fitness, with Jean-Jacques Rousseau advocating physical education for children, linking fitness to national strength.
The 19th century introduced structured systems like Friedrich Ludwig Jahn’s Turner system, blending gymnastics with patriotism, and Pehr Henrik Ling’s Swedish gymnastics, promoting exercise for health. These early gymnasiums featured basic equipment like pommel horses and climbing ropes. Later, innovators like George Barker Windship popularized strength machines, though their impact was short-lived.
Modern gym culture emerged in the late 19th century, spearheaded by Eugene Sandow, whose gymnasium and emphasis on structured fitness popularized weightlifting. By the early 20th century, gyms resembling today’s fitness centers appeared, but regular exercise remained uncommon until the jogging and aerobics booms of the 1960s and 70s.
Bodybuilding and powerlifting gained prominence in the 1980s, driven by figures like Arnold Schwarzenegger and the popularity of wrestling. Today, gyms are central to fitness culture, with social media and boutique studios shaping modern trends. This evolution sets the stage for understanding the unique intersection of gym culture and LGBTQ+ identity, particularly its significance for gay men.
The Intersection of Gym Culture and Gay Identity in the 1970s
According to a 2015 San Francisco Bay Area article, the 1970s marked a transformative era for both gay liberation and gym culture, with the two becoming deeply intertwined. During this time, gyms were not just places for exercise—they served as vibrant social hubs where gay men could connect with friends, lovers, and community members. In cities like San Francisco, neighborhoods such as Polk Street, Eureka Valley, and the Castro became cultural epicenters, filled with young gay men proudly displaying their gym-sculpted physiques in tight jeans and t-shirts. This aesthetic, characterized by cropped hair and mustaches, came to define the iconic "Castro clone" look.
Gyms also offered a sense of belonging and affirmation for gay men at a time when societal acceptance was limited. They became safe spaces for fostering camaraderie and exploring identity, with many gyms functioning as extensions of the nightlife scene. Popular songs of the era, like The Village People’s “YMCA,” reflected this unique cultural overlap. The group’s homoerotic imagery and celebration of hyper-masculinity resonated with gay audiences, and their music often played in the packed clubs and cafes of the time.
Although research on the subject is sparse, anecdotal evidence and online forums suggest that YMCAs in the 1970s were not only affordable lodging and fitness centers for gay men but also popular cruising spots. The subtext of “YMCA” as an anthem for connection and liberation reinforced this dual purpose, reflecting the blend of fitness, community, and sexual freedom that defined the era’s gym culture.
By the end of the decade, gym culture had firmly established itself as a cornerstone of gay identity, paving the way for its continued significance in the decades to come.
Disco, Nightclubs, and the Rise of Gay Gym Culture
The 1970s witnessed the intersection of disco and gym culture, creating a unique connection that significantly influenced the LGBTQ+ community. According to a 2018 article published by Bunk (University of Richmond), the disco movement played a pivotal role in shaping gay gym culture during this period. Disco, which emerged from marginalized communities—including people of color and the LGBTQ+ community—gained mainstream popularity in the mid-70s. Its vibrant aesthetic and focus on self-expression spilled over into workout culture, linking gay nightclubs and health clubs in a shared celebration of style and body consciousness.
One notable figure in this era was John Blair, a Los Angeles party promoter who opened the Body Center in the early 1970s, often regarded as the first gay gym. Featuring Nautilus machines, a lively atmosphere of ABBA hits, and a fashion-forward aesthetic of tiny shorts and tube socks, the gym epitomized the blending of nightclub and fitness culture. Blair’s promotional strategies, including offering free memberships to attractive attendees from Studio 54, further cemented the link between gay nightlife and the gym scene.
These gyms primarily emerged in urban centers, aligning with the concentration of LGBTQ+ populations in cities, which were more liberal and welcoming environments. As these fitness hubs proliferated, they became not just places for exercise but also spaces for community-building and self-expression.
Another critical figure was Richard Simmons, who founded the Anatomy Asylum in 1974. This gym catered to individuals often excluded from mainstream fitness culture, including gay men and plus-size women. Simmons’ flamboyant style and inclusive ethos provided a welcoming space for those who felt alienated elsewhere, making him an iconic figure in fitness and LGBTQ+ visibility. His influence extended beyond the gym, popularizing camp aesthetics and inclusivity through his television appearances and workout videos.
The blending of disco, fitness, and LGBTQ+ culture in the 1970s laid the groundwork for the vibrant, inclusive gym culture we see today, where health clubs often double as social hubs and spaces of self-expression.
The Evolution of Gay Gym Culture in the '80s, '90s, and Beyond
The 1980s and 1990s marked a pivotal period for gay gym culture, driven in part by the HIV/AIDS crisis. With the health of the community under siege, many gay men turned to fitness as a way to assert control over their bodies and prioritize well-being. Gym culture became a cornerstone of daily life, fostering a sense of empowerment and resilience. During this era, asking someone where they worked out was as common as today’s casual inquiries about zodiac signs, underscoring the gym's role as a vital social and cultural hub.
Moving into the 2000s, gym culture began to diversify, giving rise to distinct LGBTQ+ social subgroups. Erick Alvarez, a personal trainer, identified six principal groups in his 2007 book Muscle Boys: Gay Gym Culture, based on surveys of nearly 6,000 gay male gym enthusiasts:
- The Muscle Boy: Men aged 18 to 40 who did not strongly identify with other gym subcultures.
- The Older Male: Baby boomers who maintained consistent gym routines.
- The Poz Jock: HIV-positive men who used fitness as a tool for managing their health.
- The Athlete: Individuals who incorporated gym workouts as cross-training for their sports.
- The Circuit Boy: Men who balanced intense training with an active party lifestyle.
- The Muscle Bear: Big, burly, and exceptionally strong men, embodying the bear subculture.
Although Alvarez’s classifications reflect the gym culture of the early 2000s, they remain a testament to the diverse ways LGBTQ+ individuals engaged with fitness. However, these groupings also highlight the tendency to oversimplify identities within the gay community. Much like labels such as "twink" or "bear," these categories can be limiting, underscoring the evolving and fluid nature of gym culture as it intersects with LGBTQ+ identities.
Societal Conceptions of Masculinity in Gay Gym Culture
The cultural history of gym culture among gay men reveals a deeper connection to societal conceptions of masculinity. Throughout the decades, the pursuit of fitness has been shaped by broader ideals about what it means to be masculine—ideals that often create tension for gay men navigating self-image and relationships. These societal constructs, while evolving, continue to influence how gay men view themselves and their place in the world.
A 2009 study in Psychology of Men & Masculinities explored the effects of masculine ideals on gay men. The researchers highlighted how masculinity, as a social construct, has been defined by dominant cultural norms. Traditionally, masculinity has been tied to traits like emotional restraint, risk-taking, competitiveness, and the rejection of anything perceived as feminine. These rigid standards have historically marginalized those who deviate from them, including gay men.
The study also discussed how traditional gender role socialization leads men to face conflicts in four areas: achieving success, restricting emotions, limiting affection toward other men, and being career-driven. For gay men, these expectations are often further complicated by societal perceptions that equate being gay with lacking masculinity.
Gay Men’s Distinct Relationship with Masculinity
Despite societal norms, the study acknowledged that gay men often develop distinct masculinity ideologies. While some gay men reject traditional masculine ideals, others may strive to align with them, valuing traits like physical strength and emotional restraint. Research has shown that many gay men prefer partners who embody stereotypically masculine qualities, such as dominance, athleticism, and the ability to pass as heterosexual in public.
However, this pursuit of masculinity can have adverse effects. For men in general—and gay men specifically—conflicts with traditional masculine ideals have been linked to psychological distress, shame, and reluctance to seek help. This distress often stems from internalized notions of failure to meet these ideals or trauma from early experiences with gender role socialization.
Body Image and Masculinity
The pressure to conform to masculine ideals significantly impacts body image among gay men. According to the study, many gay men experience dissatisfaction if they fail to achieve the “physically powerful” masculine ideal. Nearly 24% of survey respondents in the study struggled to identify any positive impact of masculine ideals on their self-image. Among those who did, some cited benefits like improved physical fitness, career success, and the expansion of traditional masculinity to include diverse representations, including gay men.
However, the negative implications were more pronounced. Respondents noted that the pressure to conform to masculine ideals often led to feelings of inadequacy, obsession with gym and diet regimes, and reliance on substances like steroids. Others expressed discomfort with effeminate gay men and found themselves avoiding emotional expression out of fear of appearing unmasculine.
Gym Class Trauma and Its Lingering Effects on Queer Men
For many gay men, negative experiences with masculinity begin in childhood, particularly in gym class. As detailed in a 2019 Gay Times article, gym class was often a space where queer students felt the sting of exclusion and ridicule. Those who didn’t fit the mold of traditional masculinity—like the rugby boys—faced cruel jokes, body shaming, and humiliation. The experience of being mocked for not excelling at sports or trying to participate only to fail created lasting emotional scars for many. These early encounters in gym class can leave a deep sense of vulnerability, reinforcing societal messages that fitness spaces are reserved for those who conform to rigid gender expectations.
For queer individuals, the trauma of being bullied for their perceived gender nonconformity can be compounded by the realization that these experiences may follow them into adulthood. Many feel either alienated from fitness culture altogether or are driven to extremes, trying to achieve an unattainable ideal of the "perfect" body.
Freelance writer Jake Hall's reflections on masculinity underscore this struggle: he linked sports with masculinity, a construct that made him feel vulnerable because it didn’t align with his true self. This disconnection often leads to disengagement from fitness altogether, as the pressure to conform to traditional masculine ideals can feel overwhelming.
These early experiences not only shape how queer individuals relate to fitness but also influence their broader relationships with their bodies, pushing them either toward rejection or obsession with achieving a certain physical standard. As a result, the trauma associated with gym class and the associated feelings of inadequacy continue to reverberate, often making fitness spaces seem inaccessible or intimidating.
Media Influence and the Fetishization of the "Perfect Body"
Media representation also plays a role in shaping the masculine ideal for gay men. This ideal typically centers around being white, straight-acting, muscular, and well-groomed—a standard that often excludes the diversity within the gay community. Media portrayals, including those in popular culture, often amplify these images, leaving little room for body diversity or non-conformity to masculine norms. Shows and films are often cited for reinforcing these unrealistic standards, which can have a detrimental effect on self-image.
This media-driven ideal extends beyond traditional entertainment into the realms of social media and dating apps. The rise of platforms like Instagram and the influence of celebrity culture have further reinforced the notion that a "perfect" body is essential for validation, with both straight and gay men facing immense pressure to conform to these ideals. The desire to achieve this perfect look—embodied by toned, muscular physiques—is driven not just by personal aspiration but by an external push to meet expectations that are perpetuated through influencers and media personalities.
Within the gay community, this obsession with a specific body type is further complicated by the fetishization of certain body types—such as the "twink," "bear," and "jock"—which are heavily idealized. These labels contribute to the narrowing of what is considered desirable, creating an environment where body diversity is often overlooked or dismissed. As these ideals continue to dominate both media and social spaces, the pressure to conform becomes more intense, creating a cycle of dissatisfaction and the constant pursuit of an elusive, culturally constructed "perfect body."
Gym Anxiety and the Struggles of Feeling "Out of Place"
Given these societal, cultural, and personal pressures, it’s no surprise that gay men have a complicated relationship with the gym. For many gay men, the gym can be a place fraught with anxiety and discomfort, especially due to past experiences in environments like high school gym class. The locker room, in particular, often triggers deep-rooted fears of judgment—whether for body size or perceived masculinity—leading many to feel as though they don’t belong. These concerns are compounded by the fear of being accused of checking out other men, a tension that originates from the vulnerability of adolescence but is magnified in the adult gym setting.
Moreover, gyms in rural areas can present an additional challenge, as they tend to be predominantly heterosexual spaces where homophobia can rear its head. In contrast, gyms in more urban areas may have a higher concentration of gay members, which can also be a double-edged sword. While this could create a sense of community, it may also lead to feelings of pressure, especially for individuals who are already struggling with body image issues and self-esteem. In these settings, the presence of more conventionally attractive gay men may accentuate the divide between those who feel they have achieved the “gold standard” of body image and those who still feel like outsiders.
The dynamic between homoeroticism and homophobia in the gym has been noted by some writers, with David Levesley, in a 2018 GQ article, observing that gyms often mirror the hierarchical, judgmental atmosphere of high school. Levesley notes the tension between men who are highly muscular and those who struggle with body image or fitness. He describes how the gym can feel like a space where judgments are harsh, and where past experiences of being ridiculed for not measuring up to physical standards are reawakened.
For gay men, the gym becomes a space where, much like school, they must grapple with societal expectations of physical prowess while contending with the pervasive feeling of not being good enough. The gym, intended to be a place for personal growth and improvement, can instead serve as a reminder of past insecurities, making it a challenging environment to navigate for those already dealing with the baggage of societal and internalized pressures.
Combat Body Shaming and Practice Self-Compassion
Addressing body image issues can feel daunting, but one of the most impactful actions we can take is to be kinder, particularly when it comes to body image. It’s still common for people to make comments like "You look skinnier" or "You’ve gained weight," but these remarks can hurt the person on the receiving end. Instead of commenting on someone’s appearance, a simple "You look great" is the most positive thing you can say.
The gym, where many already feel vulnerable, can be an intimidating space. It's crucial not to mock others who are learning or making mistakes. Unfortunately, some people take advantage of others' struggles by recording and posting their mistakes for viral content. Rejecting this toxic culture in favor of support and respect is key.
While being kind to others is important, we also need to be kinder to ourselves. To build a healthier relationship with your body, Psychology Today recommends speaking to yourself with the same kindness you'd show a friend, challenging negative thoughts, and focusing on the aspects of your body you appreciate.
Avoid obsessing over the scale, and instead focus on a balanced lifestyle that includes fitness, relaxation, and enjoying hobbies. Treat yourself with self-love by accepting all parts of your body, recognizing that you don't need to fit a specific standard to be worthy or attractive. Finally, moderate your use of social media to protect your mental well-being.
In the end, kindness toward ourselves and others creates a more supportive and compassionate environment for everyone.
Navigating Gay Gym Culture: A Journey of Self-Care and Balance
Whether you're considering starting a fitness journey or feeling intimidated by the idea, it's essential to focus on self-reflection and building the confidence needed to overcome these barriers. Take the time to ground yourself, and remember that physical activity should be something that feels healthy and empowering, not overwhelming.
For those already in the gym, the pressure to attain an unrealistic "perfect body" can lead to unhealthy habits and a cycle of self-criticism. The focus should shift away from unattainable standards and toward the real goal: becoming a healthier version of yourself. This means listening to your body, giving it the rest it needs to heal, and fueling it with nutritious foods—without obsessing over numbers like the scale or body fat percentage.
Ultimately, fitness is about making choices that support your overall well-being. Whether you're stepping into the gym for the first time or learning to be kinder to yourself in your fitness routine, self-care is the key. True health isn’t defined by a particular body type, but by the way you nurture your mind, body, and soul to feel your best.
And remember: every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 82. Gay Gym Culture.
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
