Why Are Straight Coworkers' Life Events Celebrated, While LGBTQ+ Identities are Seen as “Flaunting”
In the journey of being our authentic selves, the workplace stands out as one of the most challenging environments for LGBTQ+ individuals. While many of us are out in our personal lives, the idea of being open about our identity in a professional setting often feels daunting. The workplace, after all, is where we spend a significant portion of our lives—approximately 90,000 hours over a lifetime, or nearly a third of our existence. To remain closeted in this space is to suppress a vital part of who we are for a considerable period of time.
The Reality of Being Closeted at Work
When Monday morning rolls around, and we gather virtually or in-person, the conversation often drifts to the weekend. For many, this is an opportunity to share stories about family and significant others. But for gay men, these seemingly simple interactions can be fraught with tension. We may feel compelled to be vague or ambiguous, choosing words carefully to avoid revealing too much. Instead of saying, "My boyfriend and I went to a flea market," we might opt for the safer, "A friend and I did this or that."
This cautiousness stems from a fear of how our sexual orientation might be perceived by our coworkers. A 2019 Human Rights Campaign white paper titled A Workplace Divided revealed that nearly half of LGBTQ+ workers were closeted in the workplace at the time. While legal protections have since been strengthened—most notably with the Supreme Court's 2020 ruling that the Civil Rights Act protects LGBTQ+ employees from workplace discrimination—the reality remains that many still feel it's safer to stay silent.
Personal Experiences and Challenges
The decision to remain closeted at work isn't just about fear; it's also about survival. Our careers are our livelihoods, and feeling safe in our work environment is paramount. Yet, this choice can create an internal conflict, especially for those of us who advocate for LGBTQ+ empowerment in other areas of our lives.
For me, this conflict has always been present. Even before I fully understood my sexuality, I was taught that personal and professional lives should remain separate. This belief, combined with a natural anxiety, made socializing at work challenging. After coming out in my personal life, I continued to stay closeted at work, afraid that revealing my sexuality might jeopardize my professional relationships and prospects.
I've faced awkward situations in the workplace that only reinforced my decision to stay closeted. In one instance, a coworker directly asked if I was "into girls," and I lied, saying yes. The pressure to conform to heteronormative expectations was overwhelming, especially in a company where the culture seemed immature and potentially unwelcoming.
In another job, I witnessed a manager react with visible discomfort and prejudice upon mistakenly thinking a client was gay. These experiences, along with others where my sexuality was either ignored or awkwardly acknowledged, made it clear that being out in the workplace could be risky and emotionally taxing.
Legal Protections and Ongoing Challenges
While legal protections for LGBTQ+ employees have improved, gaps remain. The landmark 2020 Supreme Court ruling was a significant step forward, but it doesn't apply to smaller companies with fewer than 15 employees. Additionally, the question of whether someone can be fired for religious reasons remains unresolved.
Beyond legalities, the workplace environment can still be hostile or unwelcoming. Homophobic remarks, jokes, and microaggressions persist, and while employees are legally protected, proving discrimination can be challenging. The discomfort and potential backlash from coming out can make many choose to stay quiet, even in a supposedly "safe" workplace.
A Lack of LGBTQ+ Representation in Corporate America
Representation matters—not just in media, but also in the workplace. A McKinsey article published on June 23, 2020, sheds light on how the LGBTQ+ community fares in corporate America, and the findings highlight a significant gap.
According to the research, an estimated 5.1% of women and 3.9% of men in the U.S. identify as LGBTQ+. Yet, representation within corporate structures tells a different story, especially as you move up the ladder.
Here's a breakdown of LGBTQ+ representation at different levels within companies:
- Entry Level: 2.3% of women and 3.1% of men identify as LGBTQ+.
- Manager: 1.6% of women and 2.8% of men are LGBTQ+.
- Senior Manager/Director: 1.2% of women and 3% of men are LGBTQ+.
- Vice President: 0.7% of women and 1.9% of men are LGBTQ+.
- C-Suite: Just 0.6% of women and 2.9% of men identify as LGBTQ+.
These numbers show a noticeable decline in LGBTQ+ representation, particularly for women, as they advance to higher-level positions. While LGBTQ+ men also experience a drop, the disparity is far more significant for women. For instance, despite 5.1% of women identifying as LGBTQ+, only 0.6% reach the C-suite level.
The Impact of Oversexualization on LGBTQ+ Employees
This lack of LGBTQ+ representation in the workplace often stems from a deeper issue: the fear of coming out. According to the HRC Foundation's Workplace Equality Program, there are four primary reasons why many LGBTQ+ employees hesitate to be open about their sexual orientation at work:
- 38% fear being stereotyped.
- 36% worry about making others uncomfortable.
- 31% are concerned about losing connections or relationships with coworkers.
- 27% are anxious that people might assume they're attracted to them because they're LGBTQ+.
The last point is particularly telling. Despite progress in LGBTQ+ rights, sexual orientation is still heavily sexualized. While straight coworkers can openly celebrate life events like marriages and pregnancies without raising eyebrows, LGBTQ+ individuals often face a different reality. When someone comes out as gay, the conversation too often shifts to their sexuality rather than just accepting them as a colleague.
Being Open at Work Benefits Both Employees and Employers
Creating an inclusive workplace is a win-win for both employees and employers. Companies that provide resources and networks for their LGBTQ+ employees foster an environment where everyone feels psychologically safe to bring their authentic selves to work.
When employees can be open about who they are, it leads to greater career satisfaction. Here are several key benefits of being out and open at work:
- Eliminates the Need to Hide or Mislead
Hiding one's true identity is not only exhausting but also distracting. By being open, employees can focus on their work and perform at their best without the burden of secrecy weighing them down. - Builds Trusting Working Relationships
Authenticity fosters trust. Being true to oneself makes it easier to connect with colleagues, helping to combat feelings of isolation and building stronger working relationships. - Enables Deeper Friendships
Openness paves the way for deeper connections, not just with direct teams but also through LGBTQ+ networking opportunities, such as employee resource groups, which offer support and community. - Breaks Down Barriers to Understanding
When people know someone who identifies as LGBTQ+, it can positively influence their views on LGBTQ+ issues. Being open at work helps break down misunderstandings and builds a more inclusive workplace culture.
Inclusion isn’t just about meeting quotas or checking boxes; it’s about creating an environment where everyone can thrive. By supporting LGBTQ+ employees in being their authentic selves, companies can unlock greater employee satisfaction, stronger relationships, and a more positive workplace overall.
How to Navigate Coming Out at Work
If you're considering coming out at work, it's important to assess your company's culture and policies. Check if your employer has a written nondiscrimination policy that specifically covers sexual orientation and gender identity. Look into whether your health insurance includes domestic partner benefits or covers transition-related costs for transgender individuals.
It's also helpful to see if your company has an LGBTQ+ employee resource group (ERG) or a supportive community. These groups can provide a safer environment to come out and offer resources, events, and networking opportunities that can mitigate feelings of loneliness and isolation.
Before making any decisions, gauge the overall climate at your workplace. Are coworkers open and understanding, or do they make derogatory comments? Are there other openly LGBTQ+ employees? Understanding these factors can help you determine the best way to approach coming out.
Building Inclusive Workplaces
For employers, creating an inclusive workplace is not just beneficial for LGBTQ+ employees; it's good for business. Providing resources, support networks, and a psychologically safe environment allows LGBTQ+ employees to bring their authentic selves to work, which in turn boosts career satisfaction and productivity.
Larger organizations often lead the way with initiatives like PRISM, an LGBTQ+ ERG that has helped hundreds of companies worldwide implement diversity and inclusion best practices. These groups not only provide support but also advocate for more inclusive policies and environments, making it easier for employees to be open about their identities.
Subtle Ways to Show LGBTQ+ Support at Work
For those who prefer a more low-key approach to being out at work, there are subtle yet impactful ways to express your support for the LGBTQ+ community. These small gestures can help create representation and foster understanding in the workplace, even if you're not ready for a direct conversation.
Here are some ideas:
- Display Symbols of Pride: Consider placing a small rainbow flag in your pen holder, adding an HRC sticker to your cubicle, or incorporating similar items into your workspace. These subtle symbols can signal your support without drawing too much attention.
- Share Stories During Pride Month: If your workplace has an intranet or internal newsletter, contribute a story during Pride Month. Sharing a piece related to LGBTQ+ issues, whether personal or educational, can help raise awareness and show your alignment with the cause.
- Virtual Visibility: For those working remotely, consider adding a rainbow flag or other LGBTQ+ symbols to your virtual background. This small act can subtly convey your support during meetings.
While these actions might not explicitly announce your identity, they align you with the LGBTQ+ community and show that you care about these issues, whether you're a member of the community or an ally. These small acts of visibility can lower barriers, create representation, and foster a more inclusive environment in your workplace.
Creating a Safe and Authentic Environment for LGBTQ+ Employees
Creating a safe and inclusive environment for LGBTQ+ employees is crucial for fostering authenticity and support in the workplace. If you feel secure in your work environment, coming out can be a powerful step not only for yourself but also for others who may be in similar situations.
Being out at work allows you to live more authentically, which can have a ripple effect, increasing visibility and potentially encouraging others to come out. This idea of being the role model you needed when you were younger applies to the workplace as well. For someone new to the workforce, who may be closeted and feeling isolated, seeing an openly LGBTQ+ colleague can make a significant difference.
Remember, coming out is not a one-time event—it’s an ongoing process that can be challenging and uncomfortable. But by taking even small steps towards authenticity, you can discover who genuinely supports you in the workplace and start putting any past pain behind you.
Ultimately, living authentically can lead to greater peace with yourself and those around you, allowing you to form deeper, more meaningful relationships with your coworkers.
And remember. Every day is all we have, so you've got to make your own happiness.
For more information on this topic, listen to Episode 10. Out in the Workplace.
Tune into your favorite podcast player every Tuesday for new episodes of A Jaded Gay.
