In this podcast episode, Dr. Caryn A. Reeder examines the irony of the traditional interpretation of the Samaritan woman in John 4 and challenges long-held beliefs about women's roles in the church, illuminating the powerful role of women in the New Testament.
Dr. Caryn A. Reeder is a professor of New Testament and the coordinator of the Gender Studies Program at Westmont College in Santa Barbara, California. She is the author of several books, including The Enemy in the Household, Family Violence in Deuteronomy and beyond, Gendering War and Peace and The Gospel of Luke, and her latest book, The Samaritan Woman's Story.
In this podcast episode, Caryn Reeder examines the irony of the traditional interpretation of the Samaritan woman in John 4 and challenges long-held beliefs about women's roles in the church, illuminating the powerful role of women in the New Testament.
"What if we recognize that and celebrated women's words in our own churches? Oh, I do. Definitely do. Yeah. Women are really important in the narrative. In John's gospel, Jesus public ministry starts because of a woman, because his mother tells him, take care of this problem with we've run out of wine at this wedding. Take care of it, Jesus. And he does it because his mother tells him to, and that is what it says in John."
Dr. Caryn A. Reeder is a professor of New Testament and the coordinator of the Gender Studies Program at Westmont College in Santa Barbara, California. She is the author of several books, including The Enemy in the Household, Family Violence in Deuteronomy and beyond, Gendering War and Peace and The Gospel of Luke, and her latest book, The Samaritan Woman's Story.
Caryn Reeder grew up on a farm in Illinois, where she was introduced to the Bible on an academic basis. After college, she went to Jerusalem and studied the Misinterpretation of the Samaritan Woman in the transcript. Caryn discovered that the traditional interpretation of the woman being an immoral outcast was damaging and silenced her story. Despite the traditional perspective of women being silenced, Caryn realized that in the New Testament, women were important participants and patrons in the early Christian communities. Caryn is now on a mission to change the perspective of women in the church and to celebrate their words.
In this episode, you will learn the following:
1. How did the Bible's interpretation change over time and around the world?
2. What is the real story behind the conversation between Jesus and the Samaritan woman?
3. What challenges does the conversation between Jesus and the Samaritan woman pose to our views on gender, identity and who is worthy to understand and respond to Jesus?
Resources:
The Samaritan Woman's Story: Reconsidering John 4 After #Churchtoo
Buy the book at the link above from IVP with code: AWORLD23 to get 30 percent off the ebook and physical book (plus free shipping)
Other episodes you'll enjoy:
Hannah Nation on Faithful Disobedience in China's House Churches
Jenai Auman on Spiritual Abuse Survivors
Winfield Bevins on Liturgical Mission
Connect with me: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/aworldof.difference/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/A-World-of-Difference-613933132591673/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@aworldofdifference
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/@awodpod
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/aworldofdifference/
Website: https://www.aworldofdifferencepodcast.com
Loved this episode? Leave us a review and rating here
Chapter Summaries:
[00:00:02]
This episode is a special one for those of us who are interested in what the Bible actually says about certain women and from a woman's perspective. Dr. Karen A. Reeder is a professor of New Testament and coordination of the Gender Studies Program at Westmont College. She's here to talk about her latest book with IVP Press, the Samaritan Woman's Story.
[00:01:39]
Welcome to the world of Difference Podcast. I think there are many who have misunderstood the Samaritan woman for various reasons. I'm very excited about what we're going to discuss today.
[00:02:11]
Author's research has often been centered around issues of violence and family life and gender in the Bible. She says the women of the Bible preached about or researched or theologically understood through the lens of women has been lacking for a long time. For her, it's just a hobby.
[00:05:07]
What would you say we have gotten wrong about the Samaritan woman? Most sermons on her had all been preached by men. Once she started reading more like female theologians, she realized there was a different perspective. How do you walk through that?
[00:14:46]
The contrast in John's gospel between Nicodemus and the Samaritan woman challenges a lot of our stereotypes. It can be a lesson for us in the church to respect women in a way that Jesus does.
[00:25:15]
We have a couple of texts in the New Testament that do seem to silence women. But all the books are really contextual. They're written to particular people who are experiencing particular situations. What would you say to someone who says it's not okay for women to preach?
[00:26:38]
In the New Testament, we have a witness to women's significance, importance and contributions to the church. Maybe we shouldn't prioritize One Timothy chapter Two over this wide array of evidence. It's playing fast and loose with scripture when you don't take the time to look into something.
[00:30:37]
Some scholars have argued that what happened in the Church was connected to what was happening in Roman society more generally. Even though we have the primary voices of the time saying women should not have authority, women were still doing it. Reincorporating those women into our church history is also really important.
[00:34:31]
My New Testament intro classes are one of the classes that all students at Westmont College are expected to take. Using those as lenses to help read Scripture is really revolutionary for a lot of students. Getting the lenses to examine scripture and what it might have meant for its earliest audiences is a game changer.
[00:36:15]
Coming back to this issue of Women and the Bible. I gave the students a chapter from Kat Armis's Abuelita Theology. It sparked so much conversation among the students. I hope that it will open a whole new way of reading and understanding scripture.
[00:38:43]
Lori ADBR: In this Change series, we're embracing change. She says it can be very uncomfortable to change our minds. But when new information comes our way, we get to take it in, research it, try to understand it. She hopes this podcast has brought new information to you.
Become a patron of this podcast, and enjoy free merch. Join other patrons of this podcast at Patreon.
**********
The A World of Difference Podcast is brought to you in partnership with Missio Alliance.
Join us to discuss this episode, previous episodes or for other thoughtful conversations at our Facebook group. We'd love to have you stop by and share your perspective.
Loved this episode? Leave us a review and rating. Click here to review
Become a patron of this podcast, and enjoy free merch. Join other patrons of this podcast at Patreon.
Mentioned in this episode:
Join us on Patreon
If you haven't joined us yet on Patreon, this is your official invitation to join us as we go deeper in the conversation. patreon.com/aworldofdifference
Please consider sharing this EPS, rating us and giving us a review
You can make a difference by inviting others to this table. Giving us a review, a rating, and sharing this episode with a friend helps us bring more perspectives to the table. We make a difference in the best way when we bring in as many perspectives as possible. Thanks for making a difference where ever you are.
Want more? Join us in our Patreon Community
We'd love to have you and your perspective as we go deeper into exclusive episodes at patreon.com/aworldofdifference
Join the conversation in our Patreon Community
You are welcome to join us in the Patreon community where we go deeper into the episodes and the conversation. Join for as little as $5 a month at patreon.com/aworldofdifference
Follow the podcast at:
Join our Difference Maker membership community for a ton of exclusive content for as little as $5/month. (The price of your a latte at your local coffee shop to enjoy a whole month of content.) Lori's Travel Tips are included as well as exclusive minisodes with our guests not available anywhere else. Join for deeper conversations and a little fun today at https://www.patreon.com/aworldofdifference
Keep making a difference wherever you are!
Lori Adams-Brown, Host & Executive Producer
A World of Difference Podcast
Transcription
Lori Adams - Brown:Welcome to the A World of Difference podcast . I'm Lori Adams-Brown, and this is a podcast for those
who are different and want to make a difference . Welcome back , everyone , to our Change series . How
much change has happened in your life in the last week? I've had a lot of change . I've been enjoying my
new job. Thank you for all of you who have been praying and supporting me in this job change process .
And I know that several of you are encountering new information and changing your minds , and that can
feel very overwhelming . And this episode is going to be a special one for those of us who are interested
in what the Bible actually says about certain women and from a woman's perspective . We get to hear
today from Dr. Karen A. Reeder who is a professor of New Testament and coordination of the Gender
Studies Program at Westmont College here in Santa Barbara, California . Her books include The Enemy in
the Household , Family Violence in Deuteronomy and beyond and Gendering War and Peace and The
Gospel of Luke. But she's here today to talk about her latest book with IVP Press, the Samaritan
Woman's Story. We're going to get to hear what might be a little bit of a different perspective for some
of you about the woman at the well, the Samaritan woman. Some of you may have heard all kinds of
things preached about her, which may or may not be accurate , which may or may not be from a very
narrow perspective that has been passed down from some of us through history , from many sermons
preached , from pulpits . But today we're going to dig into the scholarship , the hermeneutics , the cultural
exegesis , and we're going to hear from Dr. Reeder. Welcome to the world of Difference Podcast . Dr.
Reeder.
Caryn Reeder:Hello, and a very warm welcome to you there in Santa Barbara to the A World of Difference podcast
today.
Speaker C:Thanks so much . It's great to be talking to you.
Caryn Reeder:Great to be talking with you as well. I'm very excited about what we're going to discuss today because I
think there are many who have misunderstood the Samaritan woman for various reasons and so excited
about your research and scholarship around this book . But I wanted to start off with just you. I'd love for
you to tell us about your background and how you became interested in your field of expertise .
Speaker C:Yeah, so going way back , I grew up on a farm in Illinois . It was a small community , a small school system .
We didn't have sort of advanced placement classes or anything like that , so going to college was just
eye opening for me. It was an introduction to a whole world beyond the ways that I had been raised to
think and understand how society works . And in college , I got to start studying the Bible on an academic
basis, which was also so exciting to me to think about how different people have read Scripture through
the years and around the world to think about how the words and what they might have meant in the
ancient times might be understood differently today. It was just incredibly exciting to me. So after
college , I spent a couple of years in Jerusalem . I was working for University Christian Fellowship as
international staff . And there again, I added on all these other layers of reading scripture in the places it
was written and understanding how the geography and the cultures of the time would have influenced
what people would have understood when they heard these stories the first time around . So that sent
me to grad school for Biblical studies . And through my education , I was always really interested in
thinking about the parts of the Bible that didn't get enough attention . So my research has often been
centered around issues of violence and family life and gender in the Bible. And this book , of course , is
right at the intersection of all of those .
Caryn Reeder 00:04 :09
Oh, my goodness . Absolutely . I'm so excited to have this discussion today because you've probably had
this many times over because it's kind of your field , but for me it's just a hobby . I mean, I preach
occasionally at churches . I did professionally work in ministry for a while , but now I don't work in
business in Tech and Silicon Valley, but I still preach once in a while . I just preached on Sunday on fester.
I feel like the women of the Bible preached about or researched or theologically understood through the
lens of women has been something that's been lacking for the most part for a long time . Not completely
absent , obviously . Women are all throughout church history and the Bible itself that often ignored or
misinterpreted through gender stereotypes or sexism. And so this is definitely your field . So I just want
to start off with a really big question , and you can take it wherever you would like and we can unpack it in
more ways, but what would you say we have gotten wrong about the Samaritan woman?
Speaker C:Oh, my goodness . Everything . Exactly. Yeah. So if you think of sort of the standard interpretation that I
have heard in so many sermons , so many Bible studies , the woman went to the well in the middle of the
day because she was a social outcast . And probably lazy as well, because why else would you go in the
middle of the day to draw water when you don't have water in your house? There's a question we could
ask. She is rude to Jesus. It just is not polite to him at all. She doesn't welcome him. She doesn't
understand his questions . He has to break through her hard heart by accusing her of the terrible sins
that she has committed of having five husbands and now living with a man who is not her husband . And
then she immediately tries to turn attention away from herself right . By saying, oh, well, right , marriage .
But what about the temple and where should we worship God? So she's deflecting attention from her
sins. And I think that all of those points are actually doing damage to this woman and her story and her
significance in the Gospel of John.
Caryn Reeder:Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker C:So and that interpretation , you can trace it all the way back to the earliest recorded interpretations we
have in Christian history , and it still is predominant today. But what have we missed by reading the
woman in those ways?
Caryn Reeder:Yeah, absolutely . I remember six or seven years ago, I began to realize I had fallen into this oxygen we all
breathe in the ocean we all swim in, where I just preferred male, even white male theologians to read.
And I was more often listening to male voices , which is what we're kind of all trained to prefer. And had
heard most sermons in my life. Not all, but by far the majority . On the Samaritan woman itself . Well, I
would say exclusively the sermons on her had all been preached by men. Most of the sermons I'd heard
through all my life have been preached by. And then once I started reading more like female theologians ,
and then I started to see, oh, there's a whole different perspective . And it's been there all along. Right.
And then it's like I remember flying back from Singapore , because I was living in Singapore when I really
started reading more about this . And I had to be at a mission conference in Atlanta , and the pastor of a
very large church and had had a very large position in a denomination preached on Samaritan woman.
And he preached on her in ways that made her sound like a loose woman who had cheated on all her
husbands . And once I knew that that wasn't likely the interpretation , I lived most of 20 years working
with Muslims in Southeast Asia, and most of my women friends were not allowed to seek divorce from
their husbands because they didn't work that way. And so I understood that even now. And I just saw her
through the lens of that , like, no, she couldn't leave them , they left her. And she makes me sad. She
needs , like, help. And so when I heard the sermon in another way, I almost couldn't physically stay in the
room anymore because it made me so sad for her. And every man and woman listening and boy and girl
that was now being fed this lens that , no, we got her wrong . So as you've written this book , how has it
been just for you, experiencing and hearing people still misinterpret her? How do you walk through that ?
Speaker C:Yeah, so last summer, I was doing an in person presentation on this work at a local church , and it was
exactly this that some of the people were really listening and paying attention and trying to take this in.
There was one woman who, halfway through , interrupted me to say, but doesn't Jesus tell her to go and
sin no more. And I said, no, that's in another story in John's gospel . It's not part of John force . So I could
just see this woman go, really? But at that same lecture , there was another member of the audience who
continued to interrupt me to push the point that she must have been a sinner because no woman in that
age could have had so many marriages without being adulterous . If she's living with a man, then she's
clearly a prostitute . And this person just could not give this up. He actually came up to me after the
presentation while I was getting in my car and continued to say, no, this is I know, right ? Wow. I don't
know. There's clearly nothing that I can say here that's going to sort of convince this particular person
that there might be more to understand about , as you say, about women's marriage rights in the ancient
world , about how early women got married , about the need to remarry so that you can remain connected
with a household in a male dominant , male centric society . About all of the different ways we could
interpret that idea that she's living with a man who's not her husband . That don't make her into a
prostitute , but actually recognize her as a survivor in a very difficult , socially , economically very difficult
situation .
Caryn Reeder:Yeah, absolutely . When you understand that women didn't have the same it's not that no women in the
Bible didn't have rights . I mean, some at various levels did, and it's very nuanced . We can't blanket
statement anything . And there were women who had financial means and others that didn't . I mean,
that's the case today. But what we're saying about her and what many female theologians have written
about her is that she very likely was abandoned by all these husbands , and if she was living with
someone , it was just for survival . I don't know what your research has shown . I've heard some people
say maybe she was with some kind of Roman centurion or something as a concubine , but it may or may
not have been her own choice . She was trying to survive . And when you see her as a survivor as
opposed to a sinner and a jezebel or whatever people put on her, then you start to see her differently
and the conversation makes more sense, actually .
Speaker C:Yes. If you read the story without that lens of, well, clearly the woman must be a center. If we just take
that aside for a moment and read the story as it presents the woman to us, you can understand her
completely as a representative of the Samaritan community who now is interacting with a Jewish man.
And there's a long history of political tensions there . We also see here she's theologically very smart .
She recognizes who Jesus is just on the basis of the conversation they're having . She asks him the
biggest theological question of their time . Right. Who are the true people of God? Is it the Jews who say
worship only happens in Jerusalem ? Or is it the Samaritans who say worship happens in the Samaritan
Temple at Mount Garazine, which was right beside the well where Jesus and this woman were talking .
And then you can also see why, when she goes back to her village and says, hey, I think maybe the
Messiah is sitting at our well, why don't you all come and see? Everybody in town goes to see, right ?
They do not treat her as an immoral outcast . They treat her as a respected , wise woman whose words
bring them to belief . According to John's narrative , none of that makes sense if the woman is a sinner.
But if we take away the idea that she's a sinner, suddenly it all becomes clear.
Caryn Reeder:Yeah, it's so true . And, yeah, this has been that . We have a lot of women throughout the Old Testament ,
what we call Old Testament and New Testament scriptures . In the Old Testament , we have books named
after two women , right ? We have Esther, we have Ruth, but also many other women , like Deborah , who's
amazing and rings 40 years of peace in Israel, and her friend Ja Il with her tent peg, which is crazy and
wild , and it blows our gender stereotypes . And so how would you say, just looking at this particular story ,
the Samaritan woman, how does it challenge our sexism and our gender stereotypes around women and
how Jesus handled that ?
Speaker C:Yeah, I think it really does . And I think , to be honest with you, I think that's one reason that in the
preaching of the church and as you say, in the preaching of men in particular , this woman has been
silenced and marginalized and sexualized in really negative ways because it has consequences for how
we view women in our Christian communities . Yeah. So I would say a really good way to think about how
this conversation between Jesus and the Samaritan woman challenges a lot of our stereotypes is to
notice the contrast in John's gospel between Nicodemus and the Samaritan woman. So Jesus meets this
guy named Nicodemus in John, chapter three . Nicodemus is a Jew, so he's like Jesus in that way. He's a
man. So clearly he is superior in that way by ancient standards . I'm not saying that . That is my
perspective . He's also a pharisee . And so the Pharisees were really well educated . They were religious
leaders . They had a lot of power in the community . And that conversation happens in Jerusalem , the
heart of Jewish power and authority and identity . So all of those factors make us think when we meet
Nicodemus , he is going to get it. He is going to understand who Jesus is. He is going to become a
follower of Jesus. This is an important conversation , and yet Nicodemus does not understand Jesus.
And in that conversation , Jesus is even a little bit mocking towards Nicodemus and sort of saying, your
response is ridiculous here. This is not what we're talking about . And at the end of the story , Nicodemus
does not become a follower of Jesus. Also, that story happens in the middle of the night . And near the
end of the chapter , there's this really telling statement that those who are caught up in evil stay in the
dark because their deeds are dark and darkness hides them , and they don't want to bring their acts to
the light to be seen by all. So contrast that with the conversation in John chapter four, right after, where
we have a woman who is therefore socially , politically , economically unprivileged in ancient society . We
have she's not just a woman, but she's a Samaritan . So she's a member of this group that from a Jewish
perspective , was perceived to be inferior and wrong in very basic ways. She's never given a name. So
that even sharpens that contrast with Nicodemus even more. And yet, through her conversation , she
listens to Jesus. She continues to engage in the conversation . So Nicodemus says two or three things
and then he's silent . In the story in John Four, the woman is talkative all the way through , and she says
almost the same number of words that Jesus does , which is quite remarkable . Her contributions really
drive the narrative forward in important ways. And at the end of the story , she brings her entire village to
Jesus, and they all become believers and become followers of Jesus. That fact that she meets Jesus in
the middle of the day then becomes really important because she is not like Nicodemus . And so with
that pairing , we can see how John Four is undermining all of our expectations about identity and gender
and who is worthy and who is able to understand and respond to Jesus, or even who is able to be a
witness to Jesus, which is a majorly important theme in John's gospel . It's a Samaritan woman, not
Nicodemus .
Caryn Reeder:Yeah, I love the comparison of those two . And I spent most of my life not realizing that John 316 is the
famous verse. You see it in American football players written on their foreheads and places . I think it's in
and out , burger under the fries . I don't know which part of it is, but yeah, it's just a famous verse. And
yet wouldn't it be interesting if we saw John Four verses everywhere and pointing people to this story ?
And I have friends that I know from my time of living overseas that we're trying to share the
understanding they have of what the gospel is and really largely basing it on the Samaritan woman story ,
where there is more of like a conversation back and forth in an exchange , in a public place . And what is it
that you believe in engaging those questions ? And I find that that conversation just goes a whole lot
better if indeed I think God is doing many things in this story to help open our eyes. And all the things
that you just mentioned that we've mostly been blind to for a long time . But if nothing else, it's a model
of how to have a conversation with somebody who's different , but to be respectful . And not only are
they different with their gender and how people perceive them racially , but there's a lot of differences
between them . And yet Jesus shows such respect . Right. So in general , how would you say it's a lesson
for us in the church in a way, to respect women ? And how do you see that Jesus respected women both
in this story and maybe in other stories , if that's relevant ?
Speaker C:Yeah, I do think that it's interesting you say that this conversation can be a model for us in the church
because sort of the traditional interpretation that the woman must be a sinner is also taken as a model
we should accuse people of their sins so that they will come to the truth of Jesus. And I think , well,
is that what Jesus does here? No, actually , right . He does reveal something about the woman's life, but
that's so that she will understand who he is, not to accuse her of sin. And so, yeah, this conversation ,
the back and forth , the slow sort of dive in, a deep dive into these big theological messages that we get
from John for it happens in the framework of the give and take of conversation . And I think that's a really
important point that sometimes we tend to not listen very well when we're in a conversation about big
ideas because we want to get our own words out and share what we believe and what we think so that
everyone will see that we're right . But what we see in John Four is really listening and responding to
each other. And I think that's a very helpful model for us to think about . And I would say in John's
gospel , the conversation with the Samaritan woman and the way that she reacts to Jesus and then also
witnesses to him and her community , that's the model for discipleship . So this is a really interesting part
of the gospel of John as a whole that I also think we need to recognize a little bit more. Women are really
important in the narrative . In John's gospel , Jesus public ministry starts because of a woman, because
his mother tells him, take care of this problem with the we've run out of wine at this wedding . Take care
of it, Jesus. And he does it because his mother tells him to, and that's it says in John. This is the first of
the signs that Jesus does that people become convinced that he is the Messiah because of a woman.
Then we have this long conversation with the Samaritan woman in which Jesus reveals really important
concerns like, hey, in this new community I'm forming , it's not going to be just Jewish , it's going to
include all the world , including the Samaritans . Right. So we see this inclusivity in her conversation with
Jesus. Then Martha , in John chapter eleven, the story about Lazarus and the resurrection of Lazarus ,
martha makes the clearest proclamation of faith in Jesus that we have in John's Gospel, it sort of stands
in the narrative place that in the other Gospels , Peter, one of Jesus followers , makes this grand
declaration of who Jesus is. But in John's gospel , it's Martha who does that . And then at the end of this
story , mary Magdalene is the one who goes to the tomb to care for Jesus body. She's the one who hears
that Jesus has been risen, raised from the dead. She meets the risen Jesus face to face. She's the first
person to do that . And then she is commissioned to go and tell everybody about this . So again, the
gospel starts because of the words of a woman, and it ends with the words of a woman. Wow. What if we
recognize that and celebrated women's words in our own churches ?
Caryn Reeder:Oh, absolutely . Yeah. I wholeheartedly agree that women have been there all along doing incredible
things , using their voice , using their God given gifts , being placed in particular places for particular
reasons , in God ordained ways to further the work of God all throughout Scripture . Very theologically ,
very prophetically . Preaching , pastoring , leading , being involved in the delivery of Romans 16 is a long
list , starts with probably I love that chapter too, complimentary and friends kind of squirm around it. And
then there's Junior, right ? Prominent among the apostles , not just an apostle , but also prominent among
them . I'm always looking at you, SBC, all of you out there who raised me, informed me, and many of you I
know and love. And there are other denominations of people who listen within the church . We have
Catholic friends . It's certainly not exclusive to one denomination or one type of church where women are
either told they can't preach or can't be pastors or both , or can't lead or can't pass an offering plate , or
can't pray, or can't this or that . There's various forms of how women have been silenced because of
cherry picking , of sometimes a verse intimacy . Right. But when you take the whole council of Scripture ,
it's really hard to ignore all the things you mentioned and the many more. I don't know. How do you
explain how you see both the Samaritan woman and maybe women in general that we have gotten that
wrong ? And what would you say to someone who says it's not okay for women to preach or teach or
have any kind of authority over men? Do you get that question and how do you answer it?
Speaker C:Oh, I do. Definitely do. Yeah. I don't think you can have a job like I have and not get that question run into
it. So, as you say, I think we have those couple of texts in the New Testament that do seem to silence
women , and those texts are often taken to be blanket statements that apply to all women throughout
history , throughout the world . But I would want to say all the books of the New Testament , they are really
contextual . They're written to particular people who are experiencing particular situations . And we have
to keep that in mind when we're reading particular statements , especially when there are statements
that only appear in one or two texts , like women should be silent . That is not a statement that appears
everywhere in the New Testament . It's just in a couple of books . We have to balance that , then , against
the fact that , as you say in the New Testament , we have a witness to women's significance , importance
and contributions to the church over and over and over again. So I was just teaching the Gospel of Luke
yesterday in my New Testament intro class, and we were noticing all of the women who are there
through the story and our participants and even the primary patrons , the primary supporters of Jesus
work . It's women who are there . Women are the ones in all the Gospels who witness the resurrection and
tell everybody else about it. That's really important to notice . The women are really important . In John's
Gospel, we have Romans 16, but we also have Paul mentioning various women through his other letters .
So Chloe, in First Corinthian , seems to be the head of a church . We see a woman named Nimfa in the
letters to the Colossians , the letter to Phylliman names. Of course it's written to Phylman, but it also
names aphia as a key leader in that particular Christian community . So if you look at that and think
about , hey, we're talking about the ancient world where while women did have different social positions
and they could have a public voice in different ways, but basically no, right , basically women didn't have
a lot of public presence in the ancient world . So to see them become so important in so many New
Testament texts , that is a really important thing for us to notice and to say, well, we've got this wide array
of evidence that women were leaders in the early Christian communities , the very earliest Christian
communities . So maybe we shouldn't prioritize One Timothy chapter Two over this wide array of
evidence . Maybe we need to think about why does One Timothy Two seem to say something different
from all the rest of these texts ? And I think there are ways to explain that and to understand what was
happening in that particular community that made that instruction have meaning for that community , but
maybe not for all communities in all places .
Caryn Reeder:Absolutely , yeah. And that particular verse has been used as a weapon against women to silence them ,
when in fact , there's very good scholarship and research to show it was very likely to one particular
woman. When you look at how it's written in the textual kind of understanding of the original intent , both
in that particular context and then the language of how it's written in a singular form to a particular
woman. And so, yeah, I think you just have to me, it's playing fast and loose with scripture when you
don't take the time to look into something that is one or even just two verses that seem to be
inconsistent with the whole of Scripture . I was taught in seminary . Good hermeneutics means that if it
doesn't look like congruent with everything else, you know, then you need to dig deep into it and not just
pass over it in a fast and loose way. And I feel like that verse in Timothy in particular has been played that
way and to the detriment of wow. Half the church , half the world , sisters in Christ , quenching the Holy
Spirit and women . That's a pretty significant thing that in the body of Christ we would want to cut off
half of it because this work is important . God's heart for all of us to flourish and God's inclusive heart
that beats towards justice and helping us all experience God's love in these beautiful ways. Why would
we ever want to cut off half the team? Right? So it's very shocking how that's been done, not only just in
our generation , but , as you said, going back to some early parts of church history . So how do you think it
happened that women were so involved early on in the church and we're having their lives changed and
we're following Jesus. The men were ditching Him and denying him three times and the women were at
the cross and everything was so beautiful . And then we have, like a few years later, we start to see it
change in terms of what they're allowing them to do. How do you explain how that happened ?
Speaker C:Some scholars have argued that what happened there in the Church sort of late first , early second
century , was connected to what was happening in Roman society more generally , that women were
perceived to have gained too much authority and power and social capital and society as a whole was
sort of turning against them . And women were being silenced , put in their houses , kept out of society as
a whole . I think that's possibly part of what we are seeing , because that's just the moment then , that the
church is spreading outside of just small communities . It's becoming more and more important across
the empire . And that meant that it became more important for some at least, to see the church
respected . And if you've got a community where women have voices , where women have authority ,
maybe that would have been seen as shameful by Roman standards . And if you want to prove that you're
a worthwhile religion , that you shouldn't be persecuted or shut out , then maybe you want to try and
correspond to some of the social ideals of the larger community , the imperial community . I think there's
probably some of that that is happening there in the early church . I would also say, though . That even
though we have the primary voices of the time saying women should not have authority , women should
not speak in public assemblies , women were still doing it. Right. They were finding ways to continue to
be significant leaders and teachers . I think reincorporating those women into our church history is also
really important . So I really love Paula. She was a Roman matron , so a really privileged , wealthy woman
who moved to Palestine and set up monastic communities that included women and men. She learned
Hebrew so she could help Jerome in his Bible translations , and Jerome actually says she knew Hebrew
better than he did. And so that makes me kind of wonder how much of Jerome's Bible translation
actually was Paula's Bible translation ? Right. Yeah. So there are all these women who find ways to
continue to be significant leaders and teachers in the church through time . And that's an important
history to realize as well.
Caryn Reeder:Yes, absolutely . I mean, it's not the only time in history . And this happens all the time , even in 2023 ,
where men and women have collaborated on something and we gave credit to the men. Right. There are
pieces of music written by a sister, and then the brother gets credit because for all the reasons you just
mentioned oftentimes , which is that it will get more traction if it's got a man's name on it. I mean, we all
know this reality , even today. I mean, there's times where we have meetings with the schools over my
husband and I and our parenting , and I'll be like, if you show up today, honey, the whole meeting will be
different .
Speaker C 00:34 :17
It's just different .
Caryn Reeder 00:34 :18
When a man is there and there's a man's voice , we all get that . But selling out our sisters , this isn't what
Jesus modeled for us.
Speaker C 00:34 :26
Yeah, right .
Caryn Reeder 00:34 :27
Incongruent .
Speaker C 00:34 :28
Yes, indeed .
Caryn Reeder 00:34 :31
So my last big question for you here is we're in a change series right now, and so was there anything that
you, over time , used to really hold very tightly and that you changed your mind on? Or if that's not
something you want to answer, maybe there's a time where you as a teacher, a professor , have been
able to help change a student's mind . And what in particular was it about that that helped change a mind
in that regard ?
Speaker C:That's a fascinating question .
Caryn Reeder:You probably get to see that a bit in your I do, yes.
Speaker C:That is for sure trying to narrow it down to one thing . So my New Testament intro classes , it's one of the
classes that all students at Westmont College are expected to take, and that can be simply the
experience of learning the historical and social and cultural context that New Testament books were
written in. And using those as lenses to help read Scripture is really revolutionary for a lot of students
when they've heard Scripture read in church , of course , or they've studied it in Bible study , but it's
always been from a what does this mean to me? Standpoint . So getting the lenses to examine scripture
and what it might have meant for its earliest audiences , it is a game changer for a lot of students .
Coming back to this issue of Women and the Bible. Last week we were reading Matthew's Gospel and
focusing in on the story of the Canaanite woman who comes to Jesus and asks for help on behalf of her
daughter . And there's an interesting , very interesting and complicated conversation that they have. I
gave the students a chapter from Kat Armus's abulita Theology . Abilitarian to read. Yeah, it's fantastic .
And that conversation around what Armus does with that story and how she brings additional lenses to
read the story and to focus on the K to Night Woman herself , that sparked so much conversation among
the students . And I had several of them come up afterwards , all women students who came up and said,
wow, I didn't know women could do this work . I thought what ? Yes. So that was just a moment when I
could see light bulbs going off in their heads and I could see the excitement of finding these different
ways of reading scripture with a sort of feminist lens that was really great . And I was able to then
recommend a lot of other resources for them , and I hope that it will open a whole new way of reading
and understanding scripture .
Caryn Reeder:It's wonderful . I think that if people haven't been introduced to Womanist or Muhetista theologians yeah,
you're missing out , because there's just beauty there , and the scripture comes alive in ways that only
Abolita is going to show us. Right?
Speaker C:Yes.
Caryn Reeder:That's the beauty of her book and so many other books written by incredible feminist theologians , both
Muhadista Woman is and of all Types and Stripes . So I'm so glad that that was helping change your
students minds . I think so much of it is just giving people stories in the different lens and then
automatically we have to reno, reckon with what we've been told from different perspectives . And then
once you get new information , you have an opportunity , are you going to change your mind ? Are you
going to stay the same? And we're constantly faced with those opportunities .
Speaker C:Yeah.
Caryn Reeder:Thanks for the great work you do as a professor teaching this next generation . I'm going to have you
hang out after this interview to talk to our patrons and ask you a little more. But for the purpose of
everybody listening right now, that's signing off. How can people find you in your writing and to find your
book in particular ?
Speaker C:Yeah, so the Samaritan Woman's story is published by University Press, so you can find it there at the
University Press website , and you can find me through Westmont College . So my Westmont College
website would be the place to go.
Lori Adams - Brown:All right , well, we will link all.
Caryn Reeder:That in the show notes . Thank you so much for being with us today. It's been an honor to try to do
justice to the Samaritan woman and give her what she deserves after all these years.
Speaker C:Yeah, absolutely . Thanks for the invitation to be here.
Caryn Reeder:You're welcome . Thank you.
Lori Adams - Brown:I don't know if your mind changed on this . Maybe you've seen the Samaritan woman story in this exact
way your whole life and you've always heard it preached and taught on this way. Maybe this is the first
time you've even heard of the Samaritan woman, and so your mind has been changed just to understand
the story for the first time . And I'm so glad that you got to hear it from the perspective of this scholar
who's carefully trying to understand all the nuances of what it would have meant at that time for
someone like Jesus of Nazareth to interact with this woman who was a Samaritan . And if there's just so
much going on here in this conversation and it just feels like it's just too much , it feels even wrong to talk
about it in these new ways. I just want you to feel free to be curious about why it feels that way for you.
And that's not an abnormal reaction when something that you've held so strongly is suddenly you're
getting new information . And I think that's why it's so important to stay curious is because we're getting
new information all the time . And if the information we've had is somehow flawed or incomplete , then we
definitely I personally want to be the kind of person who can take in that new information , be very
thoughtful about it, be curious about it, be investigative about it and research about it. And I know many
of you who are listening are the same way. It's that curiosity and open mindedness that we talked about
in last week's podcast with Donnie Aldine that helps us be positioned to be the kind of empathetic ,
inclusive people who embrace and love people of all different backgrounds who are like us and unlike us
in a myriad of ways. And that's what this podcast , I hope, is encouraging us all to do. It can be very
uncomfortable to change our minds , and some of us may have been raised in communities , cultures ,
high control , religious environments , even, where changing one's mind was considered a horrible ,
horrible thing . You may have been raised in a situation where you were taught things like the long road of
obedience in the same direction is what it means to be faithful . And yet you can still be faithful and take
in the new information as it comes . And we have new technologies coming at us all the time . Are those
things we're going to embrace or not ? There's ethical issues around new technologies such as Chat
GTP, which FYI, I am now using a little bit to help with some of the show notes . I'm very grateful for AI,
but I also realize the ethical nature of it for my college kid and my two high school children . And when
they do their research papers , we're still expecting all of them , and they still all are writing them
themselves . But when new information comes our way, we get to take it in, research it, try to understand
it. And I hope that if this podcast has brought new information to you about the Samaritan Woman and
the nuances around that story and you're kind of wrestling through it, I'd love to hear from you. The
Patreon community is a great way to interact and message back and forth and get some extra content ,
but you could also message on Twitter at lori ADBR. I link all my information in the show notes . I'd love to
hear from you as you're changing your mind about things or going through other changes in your life. In
this change series , we're embracing change . We're lamenting change . We're wrestling with change .
We're celebrating change . It's all about change . So I'd love to hear what changes are going on in your life
and if this episode may have struck you in a way where it made you think about someone else, or maybe
you've sat through a sermon of the Samaritan woman before with someone . Or maybe you've heard
someone preach on it or teach on it in a Bible study and you thought , I want to send this to them and
have a conversation . That's what this is for. I'd love to let dr. Reeder speak to whomever around the
world that she could speak to to get this conversation going . And once again, it's about change . Let's sit
in it and let's celebrate it and all the things that change brings to us, and let me know. Love to hear from
you. In the meantime , we are getting ready for some exciting things in Women's History Month coming
up in March . We have a great guest on the podcast , alison McKinney , the executive director of Justice
Revival. I sit on the board . You're going to love her. She's incredible . And I'm getting to travel with my
good friend who just received an award, forbes 40 under 40. Shout out to Shana Mazer at NASA, who's
done incredible work and also been such a help to my son, who's studying aerospace engineering
because she's an aerospace engineer. But she's invited me to go with her to Abu Dhabi for International
Women's Conference , and I'm very excited about that . So I will be sharing all kinds of things when I get
back in March from that and hopefully meet some people that maybe want to be on the podcast , say a
prayer for that . Would love to do that . There's going to be some incredible speakers there . But as we get
ready for Women's History Month , I'd love to hear from you. Is there somebody you want to hear on the
podcast during Women's History Month ? And if we don't get them scheduled for the in, we could always
have them later in the year. We'd love to know any particular people that you're thinking of. And of
course , we don't want to forget the incredible men out there . We've had some outstanding men as
guests on this show. We have some outstanding men in our community . And I really want to dig in after
Women's History Month to get more of a male perspective on some of that . But for Women's History
Month , we're going to try to stick to women's perspectives , but look out for April to have more men on
the show back again. In the meantime , I would love to know how you're processing some of the things
around International Women's Day that's coming up and Women's History Month . Let us know. Send me
a message on Twitter and a DM. I'd love to hear about it or just tweet it out . We'll get a little conversation
going . In the meantime , thank you for who you are. I celebrate you and your differences , and you are
wonderful . The work that you're doing , the life that you're living , is to be celebrated . So many of you are
doing incredible work around the world , and I love hearing about it. And I just want to say, keep making a
difference wherever you are. We'll talk next week. Bye.
Here are some great episodes to start with.