CD137: BITCOIN IN AMERICA WITH GENERAL SKRMETTI

WEBVTT

NOTE
Transcription provided by Podhome.fm
Created: 8/15/2024 3:11:58 AM
Duration: 3270.505
Channels: 1

1
00:00:03.679 --> 00:00:13.245
Who think if you're a single voter on crypto, that this could lose her the election if she doesn't come out and embrace like, Trump was all for the not taxing tips. Now she's all for

2
00:00:13.965 --> 00:00:17.904
do you think she will ultimately embrace crypto as an industry?

3
00:00:18.685 --> 00:00:19.345
I I predict

4
00:00:19.645 --> 00:01:20.505
her verbiage will. And I do think that that part of the reason why is you see Trump's speech at the Bitcoin conference. It's just a matter of competing for votes that she's gonna adopt a thoughtful position. Now speaking as an American, not from a partisan perspective, I think that's a good thing. I think we should want great debate in the marketplace of ideas. Even if she offers a thoughtful digital assets framework or policy, even if I don't agree with all of it, I think that'll be a good thing for the country. But what I challenge Kamala Harris to do is not just cite the pieties in the words. Go into detail. Say what you actually believe about self custody of assets. Say what you actually believe about whether you think Gary Gensler should continue to be in the the leader of the SCC. So I think those specifics are gonna matter a lot, Kelly. For sure. But is what you're saying is just a general position of openness is probably all the industry really is looking for. This idea that it's not a partisan issue, that Republicans are for it and Democrats are against it. It should not be a partisan issue. Now what I think you are seeing is this tendency to really embrace whatever wins her the most votes. But when you're looking at your question, Andrew, of how do you assess the seriousness of that, the metric to use is how specific she actually gets on this policy proposals.

5
00:01:53.120 --> 00:01:57.300
Happy Bitcoin Wednesday, freaks. It's your host, Odell, here for another

6
00:01:57.840 --> 00:02:03.620
Citadel Dispatch. The interactive live show focused on actionable Bitcoin and Freedom Tech discussion.

7
00:02:04.320 --> 00:02:05.620
If you're a long term,

8
00:02:07.375 --> 00:02:11.395
ride or die freak out there, you might have noticed we've upgraded our setup.

9
00:02:11.775 --> 00:02:25.050
We're ready to take civil dispatch to the next level and I couldn't have a better guest, to do that with. We have attorney general Jonathan Scrimetti here of Tennessee. Thank you so much for joining us. Thank you for having me. So, General, we,

10
00:02:26.150 --> 00:02:27.930
I just put up on the feeds yesterday,

11
00:02:28.630 --> 00:02:30.730
our conversation that we had at Bitcoin Park,

12
00:02:31.510 --> 00:02:44.485
3 weeks ago, which did actually confuse some people because when I told them you were joining me for a conversation today, they were like, I listened to that last night. So for them, it's one day. It's relatively familiar to them. For us, it's been 3 weeks.

13
00:02:45.185 --> 00:02:48.565
But I like to take that conversation and kind of just continue

14
00:02:48.865 --> 00:02:49.765
it to a degree.

15
00:02:50.550 --> 00:02:53.530
So if you haven't listened to that, stay with us live

16
00:02:54.070 --> 00:02:54.650
and then,

17
00:02:55.270 --> 00:02:59.290
afterwards consider going back and, listening to that one. But,

18
00:02:59.750 --> 00:03:02.410
one thing I wanted to to start with is

19
00:03:02.805 --> 00:03:08.505
the attorney general's office. I I I feel like we didn't really get into that specifically. I mean,

20
00:03:09.445 --> 00:03:09.945
people

21
00:03:10.405 --> 00:03:19.439
hear AG in the news, you know, they they see the headlines, you know, the AG's doing this, AG's doing that. What is what is the role of the attorney general the state of Tennessee?

22
00:03:20.060 --> 00:03:25.200
So at the highest level, we're the attorney for the state. My office, we are the attorneys for the state.

23
00:03:25.819 --> 00:03:31.760
I represent the state. My staff represents the state anytime we're sued. So any state official sued in their official capacity,

24
00:03:32.315 --> 00:03:33.935
any suits against the state.

25
00:03:34.315 --> 00:03:38.495
We don't do criminal prosecutions here. A lot of state AGs do have that jurisdiction.

26
00:03:39.275 --> 00:03:43.055
We do criminal appeals. So the prosecution happens with the DAs.

27
00:03:43.515 --> 00:03:46.655
Everything else involving the state, every case whether it's a,

28
00:03:47.200 --> 00:03:51.780
a car damaged on a state road where someone says give me $300 to fix my car,

29
00:03:52.160 --> 00:03:52.660
to,

30
00:03:53.040 --> 00:03:56.500
you know, multibillion dollar cases involving education funding,

31
00:03:57.360 --> 00:04:00.660
or consumer protection cases brought on behalf of the state,

32
00:04:01.135 --> 00:04:05.555
constitutional challenges against the state, suits by the state against the federal government.

33
00:04:06.175 --> 00:04:09.715
You know, at any given time, we have well north of 10,000 cases,

34
00:04:10.495 --> 00:04:13.775
and we stay pretty busy. So that's interesting. So you don't actually

35
00:04:14.580 --> 00:04:18.360
you're you're more defending your office more defends the state in

36
00:04:18.900 --> 00:04:26.360
civil not I guess, are they civil they're considered civil cases. Civil cases. Yeah. So, but so I'm former formerly from New York.

37
00:04:26.945 --> 00:04:32.885
I lived in New York all my life, and then my family and I moved down here 3 years ago Good move. To Tennessee. Thank you.

38
00:04:34.225 --> 00:04:34.725
And

39
00:04:35.265 --> 00:04:45.340
in New York, I think the AG does criminal cases. Right? They Yeah. So he does. Head of the police almost. Well, I mean, you get the district attorneys too, but the the AG has more criminal jurisdiction

40
00:04:45.720 --> 00:04:53.180
and they're hyper aggressive up there with the civil enforcement too. So and and we're pretty aggressive here. I mean, we're you know, we take on a lot of big companies,

41
00:04:53.915 --> 00:04:58.655
a lot of small local scammers doing consumer protection work, antitrust work.

42
00:04:59.115 --> 00:05:03.615
But in New York, I think the line's a little bit more blurred between the criminal and the civil enforcement.

43
00:05:04.155 --> 00:05:05.535
Okay. And then,

44
00:05:06.770 --> 00:05:07.430
I mean,

45
00:05:08.210 --> 00:05:09.570
I I think it was kind of funny. I,

46
00:05:11.090 --> 00:05:12.470
ever since I could drive,

47
00:05:12.770 --> 00:05:16.470
particularly in New York, it was like whenever you see the police lights,

48
00:05:17.170 --> 00:05:24.125
you'd always I'd always, no matter what, feel like I'd feel pressure. Like, oh, my God. Like, did I do anything wrong? Did something go wrong?

49
00:05:25.145 --> 00:05:47.870
And when I first sat down with you in the event space, I kinda felt like that, you know, I was like, oh, the AG is here. It's like, you know, hopefully you don't say the wrong thing. You don't end up in a, you know, criminal prosecution, but I'm glad, I guess, in the state of Tennessee, you wouldn't be the one in charge of that. Or maybe I'm not glad because I tend to like you. Well, I mean, I could take your money but not your freedom. And there you go. And I would say actually in Tennessee and maybe it's a bias thing or maybe it's,

50
00:05:49.630 --> 00:06:02.784
maybe it's it's just an age thing, but I don't feel that way with Tennessee police. But with New York, it was always just like I felt like it was almost like a they weren't enforcing the law or trying to protect people. It always felt like it was a,

51
00:06:03.940 --> 00:06:15.000
you know us against them kind of thing which is weird. But, anyway, I digress. So AG in the state of Tennessee. That's your role. What is the role of the AG in the federal government?

52
00:06:15.604 --> 00:06:24.025
So in the federal government, the AG is the head of the Department of Justice. Okay. They do all the criminal enforcement. They do all the litigation for the federal government. So the agencies

53
00:06:24.805 --> 00:06:25.305
well,

54
00:06:25.925 --> 00:06:28.985
sometimes it gets a little complicated, but the the agencies generally

55
00:06:29.500 --> 00:06:32.400
will come up with policies, will try to enforce their rules,

56
00:06:33.020 --> 00:06:38.960
but then when it goes to federal court, typically, it's the DOJ representing them. And then if there's a criminal prosecution,

57
00:06:39.740 --> 00:06:42.960
there's a huge chunk of the federal DOJ that does that.

58
00:06:43.260 --> 00:06:52.815
Got it. So but on a federal in the federal situation, it's the AG that's filing these large federal criminal cases or Correct. Yeah. Okay. It's it's it's someone

59
00:06:53.355 --> 00:06:57.535
with the delegated authority of the president. So the AG or sometimes the US attorney

60
00:06:57.915 --> 00:06:59.295
who reports to the AG,

61
00:07:00.560 --> 00:07:02.819
but all those guys are senate confirmed.

62
00:07:03.199 --> 00:07:06.900
Got it. And one of them is gonna be signing off on it. Got it.

63
00:07:07.919 --> 00:07:10.580
To me, this was always like something that I could just

64
00:07:10.880 --> 00:07:14.259
kind of brush under the rug and not pay attention to. Like I don't,

65
00:07:17.195 --> 00:07:18.175
you know, I

66
00:07:18.875 --> 00:07:28.415
I I live I live a very fulfilled life. We're focused on my family. I'm doing absolutely nothing wrong. There's there's no reason for me to pay attention to all these different specifics in politics.

67
00:07:30.409 --> 00:07:31.310
Until recently,

68
00:07:32.169 --> 00:07:32.669
where,

69
00:07:33.610 --> 00:07:34.909
Bitcoin has really become

70
00:07:35.610 --> 00:07:37.789
more of a national political issue.

71
00:07:38.729 --> 00:07:41.069
And where we're seeing these large,

72
00:07:42.009 --> 00:07:44.669
these large criminal cases that are developing,

73
00:07:45.354 --> 00:07:47.455
that all have different nuances to them.

74
00:07:47.914 --> 00:07:54.335
But as someone who's very active in the industry and very active in in building businesses in Tennessee and and increasing the

75
00:07:54.715 --> 00:07:59.444
Bitcoin industry in Tennessee, it's becoming one of those things that is much harder to ignore. And,

76
00:08:00.340 --> 00:08:05.160
that's why we're very grateful that you came down to the park. This is your 2nd time at Bitcoin Park. Welcome back, by the way.

77
00:08:05.780 --> 00:08:09.320
That the governor came down, that that both of our senators came down.

78
00:08:10.900 --> 00:08:11.720
It's it's

79
00:08:12.180 --> 00:08:12.680
it's

80
00:08:13.460 --> 00:08:15.080
really positive to see

81
00:08:16.775 --> 00:08:20.555
just, you know, mutually beneficial discourse and

82
00:08:21.014 --> 00:08:22.135
collaboration and,

83
00:08:22.854 --> 00:08:31.115
just kind of working together. Because I think a lot of us have the same goals. But, I that's just, like, the overall context of I mean, this show, for instance, in general, like,

84
00:08:31.610 --> 00:08:34.110
we This is a technical Bitcoin show.

85
00:08:34.730 --> 00:08:39.790
Like, the idea of having the attorney general of the state on the show 3 years ago when it started

86
00:08:40.330 --> 00:08:55.355
would be the most batshit crazy thing in the world. Yet, here we are and it's just a context thing. Right? Well, I mean, I I I'm a little intimidated by the technical nature of it because, you know, I'm an attorney. I'm not a technical Yeah. Bitcoin guy. So I think there's a lot we can talk about, but my ignorance is vast.

87
00:08:55.815 --> 00:08:57.595
Yeah. So I do wanna talk about that.

88
00:08:58.055 --> 00:08:58.795
So during,

89
00:09:00.180 --> 00:09:03.960
well, first of all, before we talk before we dive into Bitcoin, I think it's really cool

90
00:09:04.500 --> 00:09:16.715
how you got your position. So can we just go into that real quick? Yeah. Yeah. Sure. Yeah. So Tennessee is is unique. There's no other state that does it the way we do. In Tennessee, the Supreme Court picks the attorney general.

91
00:09:17.175 --> 00:09:21.835
And so in in most states, it's elected. It's a statewide election, very competitive.

92
00:09:22.775 --> 00:09:26.315
In the other states, either the governor or the legislature make the appointment,

93
00:09:26.855 --> 00:09:27.835
and it's a

94
00:09:28.400 --> 00:09:37.860
highly political process. I mean, if it's the governor, you know, the governor picks the lawyer they like the best and if it's the legislature, there's there's a lot of, you know, tap dancing.

95
00:09:38.240 --> 00:09:47.475
Here, the court picks the AG. So we've got a 5 member court. You need 3 votes to get in. It's an 8 year term. So the idea is they pick a good lawyer and leave them alone for a while.

96
00:09:48.415 --> 00:09:51.875
So I was not going to apply. I was working for the governor.

97
00:09:52.894 --> 00:09:56.675
The position came open. I'd previously worked for the my my predecessor

98
00:09:57.460 --> 00:10:04.440
and it had not even occurred to me to apply for it when it came open. I thought he was going to re up when he didn't I thought there were other people that should.

99
00:10:05.060 --> 00:10:14.515
There was a 2 week window for applications. I spent the 1st week trying to talk someone else into putting in for the job and I failed. I failed miserably at that.

100
00:10:15.295 --> 00:10:17.875
And so when he decided not to,

101
00:10:18.335 --> 00:10:20.515
and a couple other people that were,

102
00:10:20.975 --> 00:10:24.420
I think, well positioned for it if they wanted it decided not to,

103
00:10:25.060 --> 00:10:26.839
all of a sudden, my phone started ringing,

104
00:10:27.540 --> 00:10:30.760
and there were only a few days left. And it was a long application,

105
00:10:31.300 --> 00:10:55.720
so I didn't get it done till about 3 AM, the night before the deadline. I was scrambling so hard to get that done. I got it in with 29 minutes to spare. The day that they went on. Upload on the website or you had to hand deliver it. So would you hand deliver it at 3 AM? You email it and you bring it. No. It was so I was up till 3 AM finishing it, and I had to turn it in the next morning. Okay. Fair enough. It was shockingly stressful though for like what should be really simple.

106
00:10:56.260 --> 00:11:03.400
And there was an interview a few days later. I did the interview and I got the job. So I mean, it was this huge life change that happened super abruptly.

107
00:11:04.340 --> 00:11:11.805
I'm extremely grateful for the opportunity. That's awesome. I mean, I think it's cool that you're appointed by the Supreme Court and I think it's really cool. The

108
00:11:12.825 --> 00:11:22.340
the length of the term. So, what did you You said it's 8 year term? Yeah. It's an 8 year term. We're the only 8 year term for an AG in the country. So, we got 6 more years of you. Six more years. Awesome.

109
00:11:23.360 --> 00:11:24.900
Yeah. I mean, I always

110
00:11:25.360 --> 00:11:27.940
Once again, someone who tried to kind of

111
00:11:28.320 --> 00:11:30.180
ignore politics as much as possible.

112
00:11:31.440 --> 00:11:42.325
To me always like the shortness of term limits was always an issue. You know, it just seems so obvious from an incentive point of view. I mean, you don't you don't even run for election. But if you're running for elections, like as soon as you get elected,

113
00:11:42.945 --> 00:11:43.445
you're

114
00:11:44.065 --> 00:11:47.925
you're on the reelection campaign trail and trying to raise money. It's just automatic.

115
00:11:48.839 --> 00:11:54.300
So really cool incentives. I think it's important to highlight that, particularly if people didn't listen to our previous conversation.

116
00:11:57.320 --> 00:12:00.060
Last but not least, before we go into Bitcoin, one more thing.

117
00:12:01.480 --> 00:12:03.500
Your staff, everyone calls you general.

118
00:12:05.605 --> 00:12:09.945
Is that is that weird? It's super weird. Yeah. It's super weird.

119
00:12:10.725 --> 00:12:17.465
You know, it's the convention. They've they've done that for a long time across the country. You get to these AG get togethers, and it's like that scene from,

120
00:12:18.370 --> 00:12:22.290
oh, gosh. Was it Fletch? You know, doctor, doctor, doctor. It's all general, general, general, general.

121
00:12:24.209 --> 00:12:39.285
It's a little weird. Have you ever met, like, an army general? Yeah. I actually saw a marine general on Monday. Did he call you general? He did and I said he was a real general. Okay. I think he's just retired marine general. I'm like, yeah, that is a different league than me. I'm glad you covered the important topics.

122
00:12:41.425 --> 00:12:54.149
Yeah. I don't know for whatever that that only happened I only realized that attorney generals were referred to as general when we met 3 weeks ago. Up until that point, I was just I mean, I was assumed as just AG or attorney general. Whatever. It doesn't matter.

123
00:12:54.610 --> 00:12:59.110
So I was explaining this to you earlier. We have this live chat, that's Bitcoin powered.

124
00:12:59.755 --> 00:13:04.975
Do you know what, sats are? No. Okay. So sats are the smallest unit of Bitcoin.

125
00:13:05.355 --> 00:13:06.495
So there's a 100,000,000

126
00:13:06.954 --> 00:13:08.415
sats in a Bitcoin.

127
00:13:09.035 --> 00:13:15.380
Right now, sats are about 1600 sats or a dollar. You know, it's a free market, so that's always constantly changing.

128
00:13:16.320 --> 00:13:19.139
So, with this live chat, they can just send us sats.

129
00:13:19.680 --> 00:13:23.060
And this one guy, no good, zapped us 10,000 sats.

130
00:13:23.440 --> 00:13:25.459
He's the artist who made these two,

131
00:13:25.975 --> 00:13:27.755
paintings. Oh, sweet. And he also,

132
00:13:28.375 --> 00:13:30.235
designed all the art for

133
00:13:30.535 --> 00:13:31.195
the show.

134
00:13:31.575 --> 00:13:34.715
Like all the cover art, all the album art, everything like that.

135
00:13:35.335 --> 00:13:47.920
And one of the cool things about No Good, just like he's become a very close friend of mine through the internet And I have I I assume his mom didn't give him that name when he was born. I have no idea what his his real name is or his legal name is or where he was born. But anyway,

136
00:13:48.300 --> 00:13:52.480
they're zapping us at. So zap is like a a Bitcoin payment through the Internet.

137
00:13:53.285 --> 00:13:57.305
And they're global. They're around the world. I told you before we started recording,

138
00:13:58.245 --> 00:14:02.185
we have listeners in a 163 countries on this show, which is kind of

139
00:14:02.565 --> 00:14:03.305
mind blowing.

140
00:14:04.245 --> 00:14:05.065
So Bitcoin.

141
00:14:05.680 --> 00:14:07.940
We got sats out of the way. Why is sats important?

142
00:14:08.480 --> 00:14:11.220
Because everyone's first reaction is Bitcoin's $60,000.

143
00:14:11.680 --> 00:14:12.900
I can't afford that.

144
00:14:14.000 --> 00:14:18.180
And the truth of the matter is, like, at scale, like, most people will never use

145
00:14:18.560 --> 00:14:20.580
the the unit of Bitcoin.

146
00:14:20.925 --> 00:14:25.185
Like, even even if the price never increased, the purchasing power never increased, like, imagine

147
00:14:25.725 --> 00:14:27.985
denominating your life in units of $60,000

148
00:14:28.525 --> 00:14:29.585
would just be ridiculous.

149
00:14:30.845 --> 00:14:33.745
So there's been proposals to do the units in between

150
00:14:34.810 --> 00:14:40.829
And, you know, like the u there's, like, a unit called bits that's that's in between, that's, like, closer to,

151
00:14:41.290 --> 00:14:42.509
maybe it's, like, a 160

152
00:14:42.810 --> 00:14:49.310
bits to a dollar or something like that. I don't even know the unit. I only focus on sats. But we just went to the extreme. Let's go to the lowest one,

153
00:14:50.445 --> 00:14:54.865
and and dream big, and we expect Bitcoin purchasing power to increase. So, eventually,

154
00:14:55.325 --> 00:15:04.225
you know, maybe a 100 sats will equal a dollar, or maybe 50 sats will equal a dollar. But sats. That's sats. The second thing we talked about last time we met

155
00:15:06.200 --> 00:15:10.860
was your failure to enter Bitcoin journey. It was. It's a sad story.

156
00:15:11.640 --> 00:15:15.660
We don't have to relive that. I'm sure you've relived it in your head, way too many times.

157
00:15:16.200 --> 00:15:17.820
But we gifted you a Bittax,

158
00:15:18.195 --> 00:15:20.535
a small open source Bitcoin miner.

159
00:15:20.995 --> 00:15:25.655
Have you plugged in your Bittax yet? So I regret to say I have not plugged it in because

160
00:15:26.355 --> 00:15:29.095
we have these ethics rules about gift receipt.

161
00:15:29.475 --> 00:15:33.815
So I'm going to purchase a Bittax. I'm gonna donate the one that I got.

162
00:15:34.140 --> 00:15:36.080
I'm trying to figure out where where the

163
00:15:36.860 --> 00:15:37.920
plug in the BitX,

164
00:15:38.460 --> 00:15:40.240
and for some reason you find Bitcoin,

165
00:15:40.700 --> 00:15:49.120
it donates the open source project. Like, if you don't change any settings on it, so I don't know if that changes the rules for you. I think it's the value of the device itself.

166
00:15:49.865 --> 00:16:06.910
Fair enough. Fair enough. So so I've not tried it out yet. Well, if if you wanna I will be getting a bid ask. Gift it to someone. Yeah. I'm gonna gonna find a a school that'll put it to good use. Some bid ask Some We we had the first block that was ever found by a bid ask. So a Bitax is, like, basically a lottery miner. We call it a lottery miner.

167
00:16:07.370 --> 00:16:11.310
And the reason is because a usual Bitcoin miner, you're making little bits of Bitcoin

168
00:16:11.850 --> 00:16:17.790
every block that's found, like, every 10 minutes. Very small amounts. I mean, the more miners you have, it scales up.

169
00:16:18.265 --> 00:16:20.045
But it's a consistent payout schedule.

170
00:16:20.425 --> 00:16:22.365
This is extremely low powered, so

171
00:16:22.825 --> 00:16:29.005
you might find a block, you might not, but if you find a block, you get the whole entire reward. Right? So, like, the current reward is worth, like, $200,000

172
00:16:29.385 --> 00:16:33.870
or whatever. So it's, like, you might find it, you might not. But if you do, all of a sudden you get, like, $200,000

173
00:16:34.170 --> 00:16:35.710
from Bitcoin, which is really cool.

174
00:16:36.810 --> 00:16:37.870
Okay. So, Bitcoin.

175
00:16:38.250 --> 00:16:39.070
Where to start?

176
00:16:39.530 --> 00:16:40.510
What what's your

177
00:16:41.130 --> 00:16:42.735
What do you think Bitcoin is?

178
00:16:43.695 --> 00:16:45.075
Not to put you on the spot.

179
00:16:46.495 --> 00:16:51.635
I don't think it's fake money used by criminals Nice. To start with. No. I mean, I like

180
00:16:52.975 --> 00:16:55.875
If I were better at math, I probably wouldn't have gone to law school.

181
00:16:56.210 --> 00:16:56.710
So,

182
00:16:57.330 --> 00:16:59.030
you know, it's, I mean, it's

183
00:16:59.490 --> 00:17:00.870
it's something that's scarce

184
00:17:01.170 --> 00:17:01.910
and persistent.

185
00:17:03.010 --> 00:17:03.510
And,

186
00:17:04.370 --> 00:17:06.070
you know, because of that,

187
00:17:06.690 --> 00:17:09.430
it's a good way of transferring value.

188
00:17:11.304 --> 00:17:27.560
I'm not a monetary theorist. I'm certain that that that was riddled with problems, but that's my basic understanding of it. Like, you can keep track of it. The blockchain is a reliable way of making sure that you know what the transaction record is. You know what belongs where, who has it.

189
00:17:28.340 --> 00:17:30.920
And because it's scarce, because it's reliable,

190
00:17:31.860 --> 00:17:37.000
you're able to use that as a measure of value with other people who want to use it as a measure of value.

191
00:17:37.700 --> 00:17:38.200
And,

192
00:17:39.455 --> 00:17:42.915
it escapes some of the problems that you see with,

193
00:17:44.095 --> 00:17:45.315
international transactions

194
00:17:45.775 --> 00:17:46.755
in different currencies.

195
00:17:48.735 --> 00:17:50.675
You know, you don't have to worry about

196
00:17:51.390 --> 00:17:51.890
political

197
00:17:52.510 --> 00:17:53.010
tides

198
00:17:53.550 --> 00:17:56.450
devaluing it or otherwise messing around with it.

199
00:17:57.230 --> 00:18:00.850
So the the sort of objective nature of it makes it,

200
00:18:02.110 --> 00:18:04.530
special and different and potentially better.

201
00:18:05.105 --> 00:18:07.285
Nailed it. Okay. We can just wrap the show.

202
00:18:07.905 --> 00:18:12.405
The general has it all figured out. No. I think that's I mean, that's a great starting point.

203
00:18:13.985 --> 00:18:18.405
I like I mean, you said early, you know, if I was a math guy, I wouldn't become a lawyer.

204
00:18:19.420 --> 00:18:24.960
I think the cool part about Bitcoin is is not its complexity. It's easy to think it's very complex,

205
00:18:25.580 --> 00:18:26.640
particularly if

206
00:18:27.900 --> 00:18:36.635
you get obsessed with it and you go down the rabbit hole of Bitcoin and you're trying to learn all the different little pieces of Bitcoin. But the cool part about Bitcoin to me is that it's just incredibly simple.

207
00:18:37.255 --> 00:18:39.195
And at, like, at the simplest level,

208
00:18:39.575 --> 00:18:44.395
it's just money that's not controlled by a government, not controlled by a company, not controlled by an individual.

209
00:18:45.415 --> 00:18:55.210
It's just money for the people, by the people, and no one has control over it whatsoever. It is incredibly difficult to change by default. That's where that scarcity play comes in because

210
00:18:55.830 --> 00:18:56.330
mathematically,

211
00:18:56.870 --> 00:18:59.290
it's designed to only have 21,000,000 Bitcoin.

212
00:18:59.910 --> 00:19:02.445
It's practically impossible for that to ever change.

213
00:19:03.485 --> 00:19:04.784
If you're a math guy,

214
00:19:05.085 --> 00:19:17.184
if you're a tech guy, you can look into the code. You can you can analyze the code and get some conviction based over that. I think most people will get conviction just based off of time. You know, as time goes on right now, what we're, like, year 15 of Bitcoin,

215
00:19:18.500 --> 00:19:24.200
people have their first touch point. They're like, immediately, what's the first thing they say? It was like, oh, well, there's no way they're gonna stop at 21,000,000.

216
00:19:24.900 --> 00:19:42.645
And then, you know, 5 years goes by, and no new Bitcoin are created, and the supply doesn't get debased. And then 5 more years go by, and, you know, Bitcoin transactions aren't being censored or being stopped or or being debased. And then they start to develop conviction. I think that's just, like, humanity how humanity works. Like, that's how human humans logic things out.

217
00:19:43.345 --> 00:19:46.245
But Bitcoin, it's money that's not controlled by anybody.

218
00:19:47.590 --> 00:19:50.730
You can send it without permission, and you can receive it without permission.

219
00:19:52.710 --> 00:19:53.850
And that's key,

220
00:19:54.230 --> 00:19:56.169
and and and you can save it without permission.

221
00:19:56.630 --> 00:19:59.130
And those two elements are key for a good money

222
00:19:59.510 --> 00:20:00.010
because

223
00:20:01.465 --> 00:20:05.404
I think our society has been sold this, like, false premise

224
00:20:06.745 --> 00:20:08.125
that you have to be

225
00:20:09.625 --> 00:20:10.365
a financial

226
00:20:10.904 --> 00:20:15.085
wizard or hire someone that is a financial wizard to manage your wealth.

227
00:20:16.390 --> 00:20:33.815
But, really, you should be able to just focus on your life, live your life, have a fulfilling life, and save in something that just accrues purchasing power over time. And I think that's the promise of Bitcoin on the saving side. But then, ultimately, as that wealth increases and as your purchasing power increases and as you're able to pass down

228
00:20:34.434 --> 00:20:37.255
that purchasing power, that saved time to

229
00:20:38.034 --> 00:20:39.815
your children and their children,

230
00:20:40.115 --> 00:20:44.970
they they need to be able to use it. Right? And that's where being able to spend it without permission is key.

231
00:20:45.850 --> 00:20:50.030
So the 2 it's funny because, like, in Bitcoin, especially if you start going down

232
00:20:51.049 --> 00:20:52.590
the rabbit hole that is Bitcoin,

233
00:20:53.210 --> 00:21:09.164
there's almost, like, 2 camps. It's, like, no. Bitcoin is valuable because you can spend it without permission. And then it's, like, no. Bitcoin's valuable because it's a great store of value and you can save it without permission. And the the truth of the matter is they're both correct and they're both wrong because you need the other one, like, if you don't have both of them together.

234
00:21:11.160 --> 00:21:13.900
Okay. So that's, like, my general primer on Bitcoin.

235
00:21:14.920 --> 00:21:23.415
And you're absolutely right about the benefits in terms of of global trade or or just, you know, people that don't have access to the financial system. Right?

236
00:21:24.215 --> 00:21:35.915
I've done a lot of work with Human Rights Foundation, with activists around the world. You know, a lot of people we take we take a lot of things for granted in the United States, in terms of our financial access, and a lot of people don't have that access.

237
00:21:36.615 --> 00:21:40.870
And Bitcoin can make it as easy as as having an app on your phone.

238
00:21:42.210 --> 00:21:45.590
But from, like, the regulatory standpoint in America,

239
00:21:47.409 --> 00:21:50.630
you can break down the industry kinda into 2 different pieces.

240
00:21:53.285 --> 00:21:53.945
I guess,

241
00:21:55.205 --> 00:21:55.705
so,

242
00:21:56.885 --> 00:22:06.990
when I'm looking at When when when when I'm looking at Bitcoin in America So I titled this episode Bitcoin in America, by the way. Big title. We're halfway through it now. And now, I let you know what I titled it.

243
00:22:08.830 --> 00:22:13.490
You can you can basically break down the tools in Bitcoin to these regulated

244
00:22:13.950 --> 00:22:14.450
institutions.

245
00:22:15.150 --> 00:22:19.410
Right? So I have a venture fund that's based here at Biggwick Park, state of Tennessee,

246
00:22:20.030 --> 00:22:20.850
called 1031.

247
00:22:21.424 --> 00:22:26.005
And we're the lead investor of a company called Strike, which is based out of Chicago.

248
00:22:27.265 --> 00:22:29.684
And Strike is available in a 101 countries.

249
00:22:31.105 --> 00:22:33.605
They have more licenses than Coinbase,

250
00:22:33.950 --> 00:22:35.410
the juggernaut that is Coinbase.

251
00:22:36.350 --> 00:22:40.850
And in those countries, they provide Bitcoin buy, sell, send, and receive.

252
00:22:41.390 --> 00:22:42.930
And they're heavily regulated.

253
00:22:44.350 --> 00:22:45.809
You know, they have

254
00:22:46.685 --> 00:22:54.945
49 licenses in America because you need an MSB license in every single state. They they're By the way, they're available in a 101 countries, but not New York state.

255
00:22:55.325 --> 00:22:56.785
It's 49 states,

256
00:22:57.165 --> 00:23:02.780
101 countries, but not New York. They're gonna get to New York hopefully soon, but they have the whole bit license thing over there.

257
00:23:03.800 --> 00:23:07.420
So you have that aspect of the industry. Right? And they're interacting with,

258
00:23:10.680 --> 00:23:13.180
with regular financial institutions, right, like banks.

259
00:23:15.414 --> 00:23:23.595
And they, you know, they serve that purpose of of bridging the gap between the two worlds, like the traditional fiat world and the Bitcoin world.

260
00:23:24.855 --> 00:23:30.010
And so, on that side, it's like, okay, what is our biggest concern as Bitcoiners, as a constituency?

261
00:23:31.350 --> 00:23:33.450
Our biggest concern is overregulation

262
00:23:33.830 --> 00:23:34.650
in that space.

263
00:23:35.909 --> 00:23:36.490
You know,

264
00:23:37.030 --> 00:23:38.809
no one expects it to be

265
00:23:39.510 --> 00:23:41.929
the world of, you know, Wild West private banking.

266
00:23:42.735 --> 00:23:44.435
But in a lot of times, they're treated

267
00:23:44.975 --> 00:23:47.395
as, like, a second tier financial institution.

268
00:23:48.015 --> 00:23:51.315
Right? So that clip that I started it off with on CNBC

269
00:23:51.855 --> 00:23:52.675
was Vivek

270
00:23:53.455 --> 00:23:54.275
talking about,

271
00:23:55.215 --> 00:23:57.235
Vice President Harris's future

272
00:23:57.850 --> 00:23:58.909
crypto policy.

273
00:24:00.970 --> 00:24:09.735
And a lot of that policy is adopted by is, like, almost kinda spearheaded by Elizabeth Warren, and and Biden's administration has adopted it,

274
00:24:10.455 --> 00:24:16.795
which is almost they they call it, like, I guess the vernacular is, like, choke point 2.9. It's, like, trying to choke out those companies

275
00:24:18.215 --> 00:24:22.770
from the greater financial industry and just make their lives living hell to build businesses.

276
00:24:24.450 --> 00:24:30.310
So that is something that we're intimately concerned about. I mean, I think it's one of those things that's, like, not necessarily,

277
00:24:32.530 --> 00:24:41.945
bad for Bitcoin on a global basis, but it's bad for Bitcoin in America. It's bad like, the the businesses that are, like, leading the charge building up Bitcoin infrastructure should be based in America.

278
00:24:42.325 --> 00:24:45.385
They should be employing people in America, and and

279
00:24:45.925 --> 00:24:48.025
they should be able to do it in a nonvague

280
00:24:48.565 --> 00:24:50.345
regulatory environment. Absolutely.

281
00:24:50.800 --> 00:24:53.860
Yeah. So I just I did a letter to the Department of the Treasury,

282
00:24:56.160 --> 00:24:57.460
I guess, 2 days ago.

283
00:24:58.240 --> 00:25:01.140
They were asking for input on regulation of AI.

284
00:25:01.760 --> 00:25:06.995
And one of the things that I emphasized is we need to have a neutral financial infrastructure.

285
00:25:07.455 --> 00:25:09.315
We can't be picking winners and losers.

286
00:25:09.615 --> 00:25:12.035
We can't be going after disfavored groups.

287
00:25:12.975 --> 00:25:13.795
You know, it's

288
00:25:14.175 --> 00:25:16.835
a long way down the road to a social credit system.

289
00:25:17.330 --> 00:25:22.790
And that ultimately is just a totalitarian dystopia. I mean, if if you start using technology,

290
00:25:23.410 --> 00:25:29.030
even if it's just a little friction at first to make life difficult for people doing legal things that you don't like,

291
00:25:30.305 --> 00:25:35.525
there you know, that road doesn't stop. I mean, you just keep doing more and more things to force compliance,

292
00:25:36.385 --> 00:25:44.405
whether it's gentle nudging at first, but, you know, nobody ever ratchets down without serious effort on the part of people to reform a system.

293
00:25:44.865 --> 00:25:45.365
So

294
00:25:45.929 --> 00:25:48.350
I think Bitcoin's in the same boat where,

295
00:25:50.409 --> 00:26:00.510
there there should be neutral innovation. Obviously, everybody has to follow the same laws. If you're knowingly engaged in criminal conduct, if you're in a conspiracy with somebody committing crimes,

296
00:26:00.925 --> 00:26:13.185
that's a problem. That's illegal. That's been illegal. Doesn't matter what technology you're using. But those are technology neutral laws and everybody knows what the rules are and there shouldn't be different rules for different people.

297
00:26:13.720 --> 00:26:16.220
If bitcoin needs to be treated differently somehow

298
00:26:16.759 --> 00:26:18.779
the way to do that is to pass legislation

299
00:26:19.240 --> 00:26:22.860
identifying what the rules are so everybody's at least working from the same page

300
00:26:23.480 --> 00:26:26.779
and this whole regulatory making it up as we go along approach

301
00:26:28.025 --> 00:26:28.765
it's just

302
00:26:29.304 --> 00:26:30.605
the interim regulation

303
00:26:31.065 --> 00:26:49.600
of everybody right you want people to be scared and because they're scared they're not going to be pushing the limits and so you don't actually have to know what the law is you just know you don't like these people and what they're doing and you wanna stop them from trying to do more of it. That is the opposite of the rule of law, and that is not what we need in America. It stifles innovation,

304
00:26:49.900 --> 00:26:51.280
and it undermines freedom.

305
00:26:52.780 --> 00:26:54.080
Yeah. I mean, I agree wholeheartedly.

306
00:26:55.385 --> 00:26:58.365
So, I mean, you're So then the other piece of the Bitcoin industry

307
00:26:58.745 --> 00:27:03.805
or the Bitcoin toolset or the Bitcoin ecosystem, I guess ecosystem's a better way of putting it,

308
00:27:04.585 --> 00:27:07.085
is this idea of open source software,

309
00:27:07.930 --> 00:27:13.950
and the open source open source software tools that allow us to interact with bitcoin in a freedom oriented way.

310
00:27:14.490 --> 00:27:16.510
I mean, you're a little bit of a nerd yourself.

311
00:27:16.810 --> 00:27:18.110
Self described. I do.

312
00:27:18.810 --> 00:27:22.245
Do you know what open source software is? Like Yeah. Are you familiar with the concept? Yep.

313
00:27:23.045 --> 00:27:23.705
So, like,

314
00:27:24.165 --> 00:27:25.865
open source software is

315
00:27:26.245 --> 00:27:39.840
is is the underpinning of what makes bitcoin special and and valuable. It's the key value prop because if it wasn't if the software that runs bitcoin, bitcoin nodes all around the world wasn't open source, then there'd be a company or a person who was controlling it. Right?

316
00:27:40.380 --> 00:27:44.400
It would be it would be closer software. And then it would have really no value because

317
00:27:44.940 --> 00:27:49.440
if there's an individual in control of it, we just, like, recreated Venmo or something like that,

318
00:27:49.924 --> 00:27:51.465
or recreated the US dollar.

319
00:27:53.898 --> 00:27:54.398
So

320
00:27:55.365 --> 00:28:01.945
open source software is key to this movement. I call it, like, the overarching I call it the freedom tech movement, the idea of tech that enables freedom,

321
00:28:02.820 --> 00:28:09.880
and empowers individuals. And as a result, human humanity should flourish if individuals are able to exercise their freedom.

322
00:28:10.580 --> 00:28:13.960
And it's important here for Americans, I think, to have a broader lens,

323
00:28:14.659 --> 00:28:22.295
and realize that in many parts of the world, you have way less freedom than we have in America, and these tools become even more valuable. I mean, the most,

324
00:28:26.035 --> 00:28:26.934
maybe the,

325
00:28:27.235 --> 00:28:31.815
you know, maybe it it could be considered an extreme example for some people, but you see it a lot,

326
00:28:32.149 --> 00:28:33.289
in terms of,

327
00:28:34.230 --> 00:28:43.450
used as a perspective example of America versus the rest of the world in terms of gun ownership. Right? And you'll see the meme, like, this is what happens when they take your guns away from you.

328
00:28:44.230 --> 00:28:45.529
I think a lot of,

329
00:28:48.095 --> 00:28:48.894
a a a lot of,

330
00:28:49.695 --> 00:28:50.514
guns rights

331
00:28:50.894 --> 00:28:54.835
proponents would say that guns themselves are more of a defensive technology.

332
00:28:55.135 --> 00:29:03.530
And I think Bitcoin goes even further than that in this idea that this is a this is a technology, and the greater open source movement is a technology that allows

333
00:29:03.990 --> 00:29:06.730
individuals to defend themselves rather than,

334
00:29:07.670 --> 00:29:08.970
you know, you know, more

335
00:29:09.990 --> 00:29:15.850
projecting power. It's more of a defensive kind of technique. So, anyway, with with open source software,

336
00:29:17.115 --> 00:29:29.855
we want a we in America, as an American, it would be nice it would be it's it's incredibly important to have a diverse ecosystem of open source tools and developers that are able to work on them without fear.

337
00:29:30.500 --> 00:29:32.760
And right now, the main concern

338
00:29:33.300 --> 00:29:35.080
that most developers have,

339
00:29:36.260 --> 00:29:40.360
most open source developers have when I talk to them So, just for some context,

340
00:29:41.220 --> 00:29:43.160
and for the new listeners out there,

341
00:29:44.165 --> 00:29:45.705
I'm the cofounder of OpenSats,

342
00:29:46.085 --> 00:29:47.385
which is a 501c3

343
00:29:47.845 --> 00:29:49.865
that's focused on supporting open source developers.

344
00:29:50.245 --> 00:29:51.785
We run on a Bitcoin standard.

345
00:29:52.325 --> 00:29:55.865
Our any donations that come in, whether they are Bitcoin or dollars,

346
00:29:56.220 --> 00:29:58.880
we convert to bitcoin and hold as bitcoin.

347
00:29:59.980 --> 00:30:04.640
And we pay all of our grants out as bitcoin. And so right now, we have grant recipients,

348
00:30:05.580 --> 00:30:13.345
in 40 plus countries. They're receiving bitcoin on a monthly basis for their open source tools that they can't inherently monetize because they're open source tools.

349
00:30:13.805 --> 00:30:17.185
And so as a result, I have a lot of conversations with these developers.

350
00:30:17.725 --> 00:30:20.705
And a lot of those conversations recently have become,

351
00:30:23.190 --> 00:30:31.929
you know, I don't really make much money doing this. I'm really glad that OpenSets exists and is paying me grants. But, you know, I could probably make more money in the private sector doing something I hate.

352
00:30:32.309 --> 00:30:40.505
And maybe I shouldn't be working on these tools because they could get me caught up in some kind of criminal litigation that I wasn't expecting, that

353
00:30:41.044 --> 00:30:43.044
that was not intentional, that was not,

354
00:30:45.205 --> 00:30:50.505
you know, that that was me just providing this tool out for people. And just one other piece of this, with Bitcoin,

355
00:30:51.330 --> 00:30:53.110
like, do you understand the concept

356
00:30:54.130 --> 00:30:56.309
of self custody bitcoin versus

357
00:30:56.610 --> 00:30:57.750
custodial bitcoin?

358
00:30:58.450 --> 00:31:08.595
I assume custodial is where someone else gives you access to the wallet Yeah. So like and they take the data. With custodial custodial is just the default across all financial tools.

359
00:31:08.895 --> 00:31:11.155
Right? It's like, if you have money in a bank account,

360
00:31:11.695 --> 00:31:20.835
like, ultimately you have to ask Chase Chase's permission to get access to that money. Right? And our whole financial system relies on trust, so everything is custodial. You know, even, like, if you have stock,

361
00:31:21.169 --> 00:31:32.150
like, and and and the stock market crashes like it did last Monday, like, you better hope Charles Schwab is online because otherwise, you're not gonna be able to access your stock and Charles Schwab is offline. Right? So a tool like Strike

362
00:31:32.690 --> 00:31:35.350
or Coinbase or something like that, these heavily regulated

363
00:31:35.730 --> 00:31:37.455
companies, closed source products,

364
00:31:38.394 --> 00:31:43.455
they're all custodial by nature. They're holding your bitcoin for you. And it's a similar customer

365
00:31:44.075 --> 00:31:46.335
customer financial institution kind of,

366
00:31:48.809 --> 00:31:55.950
relationship. Right? Where they're holding your money for you, and you're asking them permission to get access to your money. But they're giving you a service for it, a convenience.

367
00:31:56.649 --> 00:32:01.870
Maybe you don't trust yourself holding your bitcoin yourself, you know, peace of mind, security, and whatnot.

368
00:32:02.215 --> 00:32:06.635
And then you have self custody, which is this kind of a radical new concept. Like,

369
00:32:06.935 --> 00:32:07.435
previously,

370
00:32:07.735 --> 00:32:12.475
in terms of money, like, the only way you could self custody something is, like, if you had, like, gold bars

371
00:32:12.855 --> 00:32:15.140
and you kept them under your bed. Right?

372
00:32:15.440 --> 00:32:22.820
Bitcoin allows you to do that on, like, a whole another level because, you know, you can have it on your phone. You can have it on a small USB device.

373
00:32:23.360 --> 00:32:25.060
It doesn't weigh anything.

374
00:32:26.000 --> 00:32:30.875
You can actually secure it much better than securing gold under your bed. There's this, I mean,

375
00:32:32.055 --> 00:32:38.235
going down the rabbit hole. There's this idea of multisig where you can have it in multiple jurisdictions. You can have 3 keys in different jurisdictions

376
00:32:39.095 --> 00:32:48.110
and you need 2 of those keys to spend your Bitcoin. And no one can take it from you unless they have those 2 of those 3 keys. And you don't have to ask anyone's permission to do it.

377
00:32:49.289 --> 00:32:51.549
So that's self custody bitcoin. And so there's

378
00:32:51.850 --> 00:32:55.070
this industry heavily relies on this idea of

379
00:32:55.450 --> 00:32:59.470
not even idea, in practice of open source tools, open source bitcoin wallets,

380
00:33:00.065 --> 00:33:04.165
that you hold self custody bitcoin. And up until this point,

381
00:33:05.105 --> 00:33:06.565
in America at least,

382
00:33:07.585 --> 00:33:09.445
they have not been treated as

383
00:33:09.825 --> 00:33:11.125
money services businesses.

384
00:33:12.630 --> 00:33:15.530
So all of those licenses, everything that Strike has,

385
00:33:15.990 --> 00:33:17.530
everything that Coinbase has,

386
00:33:17.910 --> 00:33:25.690
they don't they haven't needed those licenses. They're not expected to get those licenses. They're never touching any customers' money. They don't have customers.

387
00:33:26.145 --> 00:33:30.725
They're literally just shipping code and people are using that code to hold Bitcoin themselves.

388
00:33:32.385 --> 00:33:41.720
And so that's the key fear. I I think that's where most of the fear comes down to is if you're a developer of a money service business, if if you're a developer

389
00:33:42.100 --> 00:33:45.880
of Probably not a money service business. Yeah. If you're a developer of an open source project

390
00:33:46.260 --> 00:33:52.200
and you're considered a money service business, all of a sudden it opens up this massive can of worms of quote unquote non compliance

391
00:33:52.815 --> 00:34:00.914
that you didn't believe that you needed to comply with in the 1st place. And I think it's practically un American to have to comply with that. So that was very long winded.

392
00:34:01.855 --> 00:34:04.434
But I wanted to give you the primer because I know you're not,

393
00:34:05.050 --> 00:34:05.930
you know, that,

394
00:34:06.570 --> 00:34:21.295
deep in the Bitcoin space and how we think about these things. Sure. I mean, I think the law needs to be clear. I mean, it's I've said it at the panel. I'll say it again. The most important thing the law can be the most important thing the law can be is clear because if you don't know exactly what it is, you don't know what needs to change, you don't

395
00:34:21.595 --> 00:34:24.335
know, you know, what changes would fix the problem.

396
00:34:24.715 --> 00:34:34.220
So if the law is clear, everybody knows what the rules are. If they don't like the rules, they can work to change them. If the law is not clear, if people start making things up as they go along

397
00:34:34.599 --> 00:34:39.740
then you end up with this, you know, really scary situation where nobody wants to innovate,

398
00:34:40.680 --> 00:34:48.615
nobody wants to speak up about it necessarily because they're worried that they may get caught in some gray area by people who don't like what they're saying. It's a real problem.

399
00:34:49.234 --> 00:34:53.015
So, you know, I tend to take the approach if the law doesn't clearly state

400
00:34:53.315 --> 00:34:54.455
that something's illegal,

401
00:34:54.994 --> 00:34:55.895
then it's legal.

402
00:34:56.835 --> 00:34:59.734
I think that's traditionally the western approach to things

403
00:35:00.280 --> 00:35:00.780
And,

404
00:35:01.480 --> 00:35:03.340
you know, if it's not clearly defined

405
00:35:03.640 --> 00:35:07.500
what what violation is happening and if people are reinterpreting

406
00:35:08.520 --> 00:35:16.165
and it is a new context. I mean, I I understand why people are struggling to figure out how to carry over existing legal concepts

407
00:35:16.545 --> 00:35:17.925
to a very different technological

408
00:35:18.225 --> 00:35:26.490
context. We've seen that, you know, in in all sorts of different types of technology over the last 20 or 30 years and the courts have not been great at it. I mean I remember there was a case

409
00:35:27.450 --> 00:35:31.230
not that long ago maybe maybe 25 years ago talking about the Internet

410
00:35:31.530 --> 00:35:41.375
where it was like Internet in all caps and you know clearly this was somebody who who was reading articles from 15 years before to understand what DARPA was up to.

411
00:35:41.915 --> 00:35:44.175
So the law has not been great about it, but,

412
00:35:44.795 --> 00:35:46.735
you know, unless you can point to

413
00:35:47.675 --> 00:35:50.335
clearly how each element of a given crime

414
00:35:50.635 --> 00:35:53.615
is is being violated by the person doing it,

415
00:35:55.090 --> 00:35:57.750
you you shouldn't go after him and same with civil enforcement

416
00:35:58.130 --> 00:36:08.390
if somebody's actively deceiving people that's a problem right there are plenty of scammers in the bitcoin world just like in the real world and you know that's not a bitcoin issue that's a scammer issue

417
00:36:08.849 --> 00:36:10.775
but if you're making tools

418
00:36:11.315 --> 00:36:13.974
and you're not engaged in any sort

419
00:36:15.155 --> 00:36:25.620
of knowing collusion with somebody who's going to use them to break the law and is relying on you to make them a certain way so that they can do whatever crimes they want to do. If you're just putting tools out there

420
00:36:26.880 --> 00:36:29.140
and if it's not clear that they should be

421
00:36:29.520 --> 00:36:31.140
subject to a given regulation

422
00:36:31.760 --> 00:36:46.355
you know maybe maybe there's some gray area and someone honestly didn't know that they were violating a law but in that case, you don't need the big bad government to come in and swat them down. That's just going to discourage anybody from doing anything that might potentially be a problem.

423
00:36:46.975 --> 00:36:49.715
So so if someone does inadvertently cross a line,

424
00:36:50.175 --> 00:36:52.035
if it's really a good faith mistake,

425
00:36:52.920 --> 00:36:54.859
you you don't smack them. I mean, you'd

426
00:36:55.319 --> 00:37:01.260
help them solve the problem and do what they're supposed to do. But if it's not clear that there's a line that they're crossing,

427
00:37:01.720 --> 00:37:16.165
then rewrite the law if you don't like what they're doing. You you don't just start enforcing things arbitrarily in a very broad way. That's not how the law is supposed to work and it undermines prosperity so much because nobody wants to go out and try new things nobody wants to innovate

428
00:37:16.545 --> 00:37:18.405
nobody wants to be bold or brave

429
00:37:18.865 --> 00:37:23.525
and you end up with a very timid economy full of people who are are content with stagnation

430
00:37:25.000 --> 00:37:27.660
So, I mean, if you put yourself in our shoes,

431
00:37:29.080 --> 00:37:32.620
with the the the the fears and the concerns that I've

432
00:37:33.000 --> 00:37:34.060
explained to you,

433
00:37:34.600 --> 00:37:39.740
and we can make let's we'll make this American specific, and we can make this even Tennessee specific,

434
00:37:40.665 --> 00:37:43.645
because it's in your wheelhouse. You're a lawyer by trade.

435
00:37:45.465 --> 00:37:50.205
Like, what is our best course of action? Like, I I don't wanna just, like, sit on my hands

436
00:37:50.585 --> 00:37:59.010
and wait and see if, you know, friends get thrown in jail or have, like, a SWAT team come through their door. Like, how do we how do we make the best of this? I mean I think

437
00:38:00.349 --> 00:38:02.130
the 2 best things to do are

438
00:38:02.510 --> 00:38:08.609
first educate people get out there and explain what's going on explain like hey these open source developers are making tools

439
00:38:09.245 --> 00:38:13.585
and you know if somebody goes to Home Depot and buys a hammer and kills someone with it.

440
00:38:14.045 --> 00:38:17.425
You don't go to Home Depot and start arresting the people who sold the hammer.

441
00:38:18.445 --> 00:38:23.460
You know if if the guy comes in and says I need a hammer to kill somebody you're in a different situation maybe but Right.

442
00:38:24.339 --> 00:38:30.119
You know, it these are That's where the conspiracy part Exactly. Exactly. It's all about the mental state at the time.

443
00:38:31.060 --> 00:38:32.440
The second thing is

444
00:38:33.140 --> 00:38:36.760
get organized as an industry, as a community,

445
00:38:37.494 --> 00:38:39.195
and get more active lobbying,

446
00:38:39.974 --> 00:38:45.915
which I think is what's happening. I mean, I I was not super engaged with the Nashville event,

447
00:38:46.295 --> 00:38:52.580
but I was here. I was over at another event on Saturday and saw a bunch of people talk to him there. You know,

448
00:38:52.880 --> 00:38:55.140
get engaged and make sure that you are

449
00:38:55.520 --> 00:38:58.660
educating the enforcement folks, educating the legislators.

450
00:38:59.360 --> 00:39:01.140
And if there are regulatory problems,

451
00:39:02.320 --> 00:39:06.335
you know, start submitting comment letters, start doing amicus briefs.

452
00:39:06.635 --> 00:39:08.575
Ultimately, the courts are the check

453
00:39:09.195 --> 00:39:16.815
on, government overreach in the short term. In the long term, it's all about democracy in this country. It's all about the people voting. But in the short term,

454
00:39:17.275 --> 00:39:18.175
it's all about

455
00:39:18.840 --> 00:39:19.500
the courts

456
00:39:19.800 --> 00:39:20.300
ultimately

457
00:39:20.680 --> 00:39:25.340
deciding what the law says and if enforcers come in reading the law too broadly

458
00:39:25.640 --> 00:39:33.740
the courts can reign them in and I think the courts have been doing a little bit more of that lately and I think that's a good thing. I think we need to be clear about what the rules are.

459
00:39:34.635 --> 00:39:37.215
But educating the courts and educating the legislators

460
00:39:37.915 --> 00:39:42.795
and being very vocal about it is the best way to start pushing back against,

461
00:39:43.115 --> 00:39:45.375
any persistent overreach that you've been seeing.

462
00:39:45.755 --> 00:39:48.095
So, I mean, in practice though, I guess,

463
00:39:49.569 --> 00:39:51.349
in like the short to medium term,

464
00:39:53.010 --> 00:39:58.390
the unfortunate reality is it's gonna There's gonna be multiple court cases and there's gonna be

465
00:39:58.849 --> 00:40:04.310
These things are gonna be fought out in courts with like people's lives in limbo. Like there's no way to really avoid that, right?

466
00:40:04.825 --> 00:40:11.565
To some extent, yeah. I mean, you know, we we've got dual sovereignty in this country. You got the federal government, you got the state governments.

467
00:40:11.945 --> 00:40:14.125
Some state governments are a lot more,

468
00:40:15.545 --> 00:40:17.325
we'll say aggressive than others,

469
00:40:18.130 --> 00:40:20.470
in terms of of pushing the line on enforcement.

470
00:40:21.170 --> 00:40:23.990
So people can move to states like Tennessee,

471
00:40:24.609 --> 00:40:31.190
where there's more embrace of innovation, where you've got a government that is at least cognizant to some extent of these issues

472
00:40:31.570 --> 00:40:32.790
and wants to encourage

473
00:40:33.115 --> 00:40:36.975
the entrepreneurial spirit. Doesn't mean you're protected from the feds necessarily,

474
00:40:39.595 --> 00:40:44.095
but you you at least have one less layer to worry about. And in the long run,

475
00:40:44.395 --> 00:40:46.895
I think we necessarily will have to have

476
00:40:47.275 --> 00:40:52.760
much clearer federal rules. You know, right now there's still some fighting over has jurisdiction over what

477
00:40:53.299 --> 00:40:56.440
and what the scope of of appropriate regulation is.

478
00:40:57.380 --> 00:41:02.760
That that's not gonna go on forever. There are too many people to invest in this issue. There are too many people pushing.

479
00:41:03.295 --> 00:41:07.875
There are too many legislators paying attention now for that situation to continue indefinitely.

480
00:41:10.575 --> 00:41:12.675
I mean, one I mean, I think jurisdictional,

481
00:41:13.695 --> 00:41:16.195
choice is a key aspect of

482
00:41:16.520 --> 00:41:29.900
of the checks and balances in America. Right? I mean, I moved my family down from New York, and we didn't have to cross international borders. There was very little friction for us to be able to to choose where we wanted to live and choose which jurisdiction we wanted to live under.

483
00:41:32.815 --> 00:41:35.715
But there's there's that piece there. Right? That there

484
00:41:36.015 --> 00:41:38.435
that the federal government is becoming more involved.

485
00:41:39.615 --> 00:41:43.795
And there's actually 2 pieces there that I think are kind of interesting and scary.

486
00:41:44.975 --> 00:41:53.970
Well, the first piece is interesting and scary. So this is all digital software. Right? So there's one case in New York right now. The Southern District of New York is

487
00:41:54.430 --> 00:41:57.970
is leading that case. Once again, not a lawyer. You're the lawyer.

488
00:41:59.150 --> 00:42:03.305
But my understanding is they're a they're a jurisdiction of

489
00:42:03.685 --> 00:42:10.744
the of the federal arm. Right? Southern District of New York is federal government. Right. It's the DOJ. Yeah. But they're based in New York,

490
00:42:11.125 --> 00:42:13.945
and they're more aggressive than maybe other jurisdictions

491
00:42:16.230 --> 00:42:17.210
of the federal

492
00:42:18.070 --> 00:42:18.970
legal apparatus.

493
00:42:19.590 --> 00:42:30.170
And, like, they What they did was they just, like, opened the app in, like, downtown New York. This is a global app. Right? They, like, opened this open source app in New York and then, like, they send some bitcoin to it. They're like, okay. So this happened in our jurisdiction.

494
00:42:30.470 --> 00:42:39.595
So we're gonna prosecute them there, which I think is kind of new. Right? Like, that concept is kind of new. Like, it used to be, like, oh, you're actually doing business in New York is very obvious.

495
00:42:42.215 --> 00:42:49.090
So I don't know what point I'm trying to make there except that this is a little bit scary. And then the second piece I have is like so how does that work

496
00:42:49.790 --> 00:42:50.770
in that situation?

497
00:42:51.870 --> 00:42:54.290
What what is so what is our version of SDNY

498
00:42:54.990 --> 00:43:02.565
in Tennessee? So we've got 3 here. We got Okay. We got an office in Memphis. I used to work there for a while as a a civil rights prosecutor for the feds.

499
00:43:02.944 --> 00:43:07.045
We have one in Nashville for the middle district, one based in Knoxville for the eastern district.

500
00:43:07.505 --> 00:43:08.404
So SDNY

501
00:43:08.704 --> 00:43:09.525
is traditionally

502
00:43:09.825 --> 00:43:11.684
much more oriented toward finance.

503
00:43:12.039 --> 00:43:13.660
Got it. They have really sophisticated

504
00:43:14.039 --> 00:43:15.180
prosecutors there,

505
00:43:16.039 --> 00:43:17.660
used to big white collar cases.

506
00:43:18.200 --> 00:43:18.680
You know, you

507
00:43:19.319 --> 00:43:20.059
in Tennessee,

508
00:43:20.359 --> 00:43:27.905
you've got some good white collar folks, but you get a lot more guns, drugs. Right. I did a lot of human trafficking prosecutions when I was there. You know,

509
00:43:28.765 --> 00:43:31.265
they're important cases, very important cases.

510
00:43:31.565 --> 00:43:35.825
They're not as complicated. They're not as sophisticated. There's not as much math involved, typically.

511
00:43:36.444 --> 00:43:41.420
The SDNY guys, though, are used to big stock cases, big bank cases.

512
00:43:43.000 --> 00:43:46.700
They they have a lot of institutional expertise and a lot of people,

513
00:43:47.560 --> 00:43:56.175
who are very ambitious. It's super hard to get a job there. You get brilliant lawyers. They wanna leave a mark, and so they often look for big cases to bring.

514
00:43:56.555 --> 00:44:00.095
And I can understand how from a prosecutorial perspective, new technology

515
00:44:00.795 --> 00:44:02.575
could be appealing to look at,

516
00:44:03.515 --> 00:44:06.030
because you you can make a name for yourself that way.

517
00:44:06.590 --> 00:44:09.730
I I don't I don't think they're intending to come in,

518
00:44:11.710 --> 00:44:15.490
you know, doing anything untoward. I think they're looking for interesting

519
00:44:15.870 --> 00:44:16.610
big cases,

520
00:44:18.190 --> 00:44:21.305
where the law is new would be my guess.

521
00:44:21.925 --> 00:44:23.705
And they see this as something new

522
00:44:24.085 --> 00:44:30.265
and they think, you know, this is I mean, if you if you're gonna be a prosecutor who wants to go into private practice

523
00:44:30.645 --> 00:44:33.464
Right. You know, having a a big footprint

524
00:44:33.765 --> 00:44:34.265
in

525
00:44:35.100 --> 00:44:37.200
innovative technology is not a bad way

526
00:44:37.740 --> 00:44:38.560
to do that.

527
00:44:39.740 --> 00:44:51.785
It's a good, like, name brand case. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, when you when you're the guy that did the big case Yeah. That's money in the bank when you start going to to law firms. Right? They wanna be able to say, we got this guy. You know, clearly, he knows what he's doing.

528
00:44:52.965 --> 00:45:00.984
And and, again, like, I don't I don't wanna read too much into their motivations. I know there are a lot of people that give up a lot of money to do those jobs because they think it's really important,

529
00:45:01.365 --> 00:45:02.505
to serve the public.

530
00:45:02.965 --> 00:45:03.420
But,

531
00:45:03.900 --> 00:45:05.920
you know, that kind of overreach, I think,

532
00:45:06.780 --> 00:45:07.680
comes from,

533
00:45:09.260 --> 00:45:13.280
from ambition, really. You know, they they see a big potential case out there.

534
00:45:13.660 --> 00:45:15.520
And sometimes when you're a prosecutor,

535
00:45:16.155 --> 00:45:19.855
you see injustice or what you think is injustice, and you wanna get it.

536
00:45:20.155 --> 00:45:23.295
But in situations like this, the law is just very

537
00:45:23.755 --> 00:45:27.295
imperfect as a as a tool of justice. Right? If you're talking about, like,

538
00:45:27.675 --> 00:45:29.935
a rape case or a murder case,

539
00:45:31.800 --> 00:45:37.500
you know, it's a black and white kind of case. It's quite obvious. Yeah. And Yeah. You know, with with virtually no exceptions.

540
00:45:38.200 --> 00:45:38.700
And

541
00:45:39.160 --> 00:45:42.380
you you make the case, and you get the bad guy, and you do justice.

542
00:45:42.735 --> 00:45:45.955
When you're talking about big technology financial cases,

543
00:45:46.415 --> 00:45:50.675
things get a lot blurrier which is why unless the lines are really clearly drawn,

544
00:45:50.975 --> 00:45:57.875
criminal law is not the right tool to resolve these issues. So then my next question for you is the so, like, where does the

545
00:45:58.200 --> 00:46:01.339
where does the state AG fall into that

546
00:46:01.800 --> 00:46:03.740
situation? Is it just completely independent?

547
00:46:04.200 --> 00:46:11.900
Totally independent. Those federal prosecutions? So there's I mean, there's federal preemption that means that sometimes federal law keeps us from having enforcement authority.

548
00:46:12.395 --> 00:46:15.775
But we have really broad authority over consumer protection laws,

549
00:46:16.155 --> 00:46:17.535
which are often pretty

550
00:46:18.474 --> 00:46:20.494
parallel with the federal fraud laws.

551
00:46:21.195 --> 00:46:25.135
So a lot of times you'll see us going after similar financial institutions

552
00:46:25.940 --> 00:46:27.160
or pharma companies

553
00:46:27.540 --> 00:46:34.360
or tech companies. We just won a huge case against Google, big antitrust suit. Oh, wow. We were in that with DOJ working together,

554
00:46:35.620 --> 00:46:39.240
but we have our own independent enforcement. So if you're in a state that has

555
00:46:39.734 --> 00:46:47.914
a lot of resources dedicated to enforcement, like New York, they've got a huge AG's office. Yeah. There are people there who are gonna keep themselves busy looking for cases.

556
00:46:48.694 --> 00:46:52.954
In Tennessee, we've got fewer resources, and we've got a much more pronounced commitment,

557
00:46:53.734 --> 00:46:54.394
to restraint.

558
00:46:54.730 --> 00:46:58.670
Right. And so, you know, when when it's time to bring a case, we bring it, and we win.

559
00:46:59.610 --> 00:47:06.110
But not everything can be solved through litigation. Not everything can be solved through swinging a big hammer. Sometimes if you need clarity,

560
00:47:06.665 --> 00:47:15.405
you need to give a safe harbor and develop the rules such that people know when they're breaking them rather than try to make examples of people who didn't know they were doing anything wrong.

561
00:47:16.505 --> 00:47:17.964
Yeah. That makes sense to me.

562
00:47:19.650 --> 00:47:22.710
So, I mean, you had one line. We're getting close to our

563
00:47:23.250 --> 00:47:24.789
to our time limit here.

564
00:47:25.250 --> 00:47:27.510
You had one line at when we're

565
00:47:28.130 --> 00:47:30.549
we're in the event space with a packed crowd,

566
00:47:31.505 --> 00:47:32.245
that used

567
00:47:32.665 --> 00:47:33.205
that had

568
00:47:34.385 --> 00:47:37.605
almost unanimous applause. People got very excited about it.

569
00:47:37.985 --> 00:47:41.205
That one of your key roles as as a state AG

570
00:47:41.745 --> 00:47:43.605
is suing the federal government.

571
00:47:44.930 --> 00:47:50.869
Nasid even put a smile to your face. Can we just talk about that a little bit like how does that where does this fall into

572
00:47:51.329 --> 00:47:59.925
everything else we've talked about? Sure. So you know in in our system, in our constitutional system, the biggest evil that we're trying to avoid is the concentration of power

573
00:48:00.225 --> 00:48:07.605
in a small number of hands. And so at the federal level, we got separation of powers. We get the legislative, the executive, and the judicial branches.

574
00:48:08.140 --> 00:48:09.500
But then there's also this,

575
00:48:09.820 --> 00:48:13.359
vertical split where the federal government has certain enumerated powers.

576
00:48:13.820 --> 00:48:21.280
Most of the governmental power is is kept at the state level. The federal government's gotten much more expansive than I think anybody originally intended or comprehended,

577
00:48:22.215 --> 00:48:26.075
but there's still this huge reservoir of governing authority at the state level,

578
00:48:27.015 --> 00:48:33.115
and one of the purposes of separating the power is that each part of the government checks the other parts,

579
00:48:33.590 --> 00:48:37.690
And there was not sufficient checking of the federal agencies for a long time.

580
00:48:38.230 --> 00:48:42.330
And now there's a lot more. And so, you know, our general assembly and our governor

581
00:48:42.790 --> 00:48:44.650
created a unit that basically

582
00:48:44.950 --> 00:48:46.635
serves to sue the federal government.

583
00:48:47.195 --> 00:48:55.375
And anytime there is overreach where a statute doesn't give an agency the authority that they're claiming, so they're doing something they're not authorized to do,

584
00:48:55.675 --> 00:49:12.915
anytime they're acting outside the scope of what the constitution allows the federal government to do, if it interferes with anything the state's doing, we can sue and we can get a court to enjoin it. So, you know, there are some really contentious social issues right now where there's a lot of this action, a lot of gender identity litigation going on,

585
00:49:13.475 --> 00:49:18.855
but at the heart, that's not litigation about gender identity. It's litigation about the structure of government

586
00:49:19.395 --> 00:49:21.735
and who has the authority to do what.

587
00:49:22.195 --> 00:49:24.455
And it's it's not just there. I mean, we're doing

588
00:49:25.560 --> 00:49:27.660
litigation over environmental regulation

589
00:49:28.360 --> 00:49:28.860
over

590
00:49:31.240 --> 00:49:33.420
various ESG disclosure requirements.

591
00:49:34.840 --> 00:49:43.695
There's appliance stuff that we've been looking at where there are just these, you know, these regulations on appliances that the federal government's not authorized to impose

592
00:49:44.155 --> 00:49:45.935
and as somebody who's occasionally

593
00:49:46.395 --> 00:49:50.575
been very unhappy with a dryer that doesn't dry clothes after 2 runs,

594
00:49:51.195 --> 00:49:54.495
you know, I'm a little personally invested in that but, you know,

595
00:49:54.880 --> 00:49:58.660
you don't check the government, either either through voting or through using the structure to to correct problems, you know, you end up with this bloated concentration

596
00:49:58.960 --> 00:50:02.660
of power in the federal agencies with no accountability.

597
00:50:08.585 --> 00:50:11.325
People don't understand where the law comes from

598
00:50:11.625 --> 00:50:17.005
or why it is the way it is and they feel really alienated from it and you can't have a sustainable

599
00:50:17.385 --> 00:50:17.885
republic

600
00:50:18.345 --> 00:50:23.325
if people think that the law is being imposed on them by faceless bureaucrats who don't have to answer to them.

601
00:50:23.900 --> 00:50:24.800
I meant to

602
00:50:25.180 --> 00:50:27.360
that. So basically, like, the key is is

603
00:50:27.740 --> 00:50:31.040
is where the federal government oversteps on the state's rights

604
00:50:31.340 --> 00:50:35.200
is where the AG steps in and sues the federal government to kind of

605
00:50:35.755 --> 00:50:46.734
establish that. To some extent, it's it's not even the state's rights as much as it is if the states are trying to govern in a particular area or if the states have decided there should be less government in a particular area. And the federal government,

606
00:50:47.435 --> 00:50:51.150
you know, impedes on their ability to set that legal policy

607
00:50:51.690 --> 00:50:57.550
then we can push back. So Awesome. You know, it's it's not like the civil war states rights kind of situation. It's

608
00:50:57.850 --> 00:51:08.205
it's really like there are rules about government. Each part of it has its powers if if someone acts outside the scope of what they're supposed to do the other parts are supposed to push back and stop them. Awesome.

609
00:51:09.145 --> 00:51:16.125
We're towards the end of our time here. Before we wrap, do you have any final thoughts for our audience? The big corners listening around the world?

610
00:51:16.425 --> 00:51:17.085
You know,

611
00:51:18.039 --> 00:51:19.900
I hesitate to even say this,

612
00:51:21.000 --> 00:51:25.000
because I know that it is there there are many theories out there but I I

613
00:51:25.799 --> 00:51:30.619
and you know you don't have to answer if this is like super gauche to ask but who is Satoshi?

614
00:51:32.085 --> 00:51:33.525
We don't talk about that. No.

615
00:51:34.244 --> 00:51:36.345
Nobody knows who Satoshi is. It's it's

616
00:51:37.365 --> 00:51:40.265
it's kind of a marvel of of modern history

617
00:51:40.565 --> 00:51:43.225
that someone who everyone wants to know,

618
00:51:44.565 --> 00:51:45.945
has been able to

619
00:51:46.680 --> 00:51:55.020
escape that public scrutiny. And it's not an easy thing to do. Like, I've I've had when we were talking about the legal conversations about developers being worried about,

620
00:51:56.200 --> 00:51:56.700
potential

621
00:51:57.079 --> 00:51:58.220
legal ramifications

622
00:51:58.520 --> 00:52:04.655
for their work, A bunch of people always say, oh, well, why don't they just pull a satoshi? It's, like, you can't just, like, pull a satoshi. Like,

623
00:52:06.234 --> 00:52:07.135
global governments,

624
00:52:07.835 --> 00:52:08.335
mercenaries,

625
00:52:08.795 --> 00:52:15.135
like, random companies, individuals that are incredibly wealthy have tried to figure out who this guy is. And no one has any idea.

626
00:52:15.570 --> 00:52:17.330
So, I mean, I would go back to my,

627
00:52:19.170 --> 00:52:31.365
my claim earlier with most people is is time is a conviction thing. And it's like as time goes on, it becomes more and more likely that we'll just never find out. And it's kind of one of the beautiful birth stories of Bitcoin in the first place.

628
00:52:33.365 --> 00:52:36.505
That, like, this person, like, stepped aside, put away their ego,

629
00:52:36.965 --> 00:52:42.105
decided that they didn't wanna be a public face of the project, because it probably would have just killed it in its infancy

630
00:52:42.565 --> 00:52:46.744
if that if that person had decided that they wanted to be, like, the supreme leader of Bitcoin.

631
00:52:48.550 --> 00:52:53.849
Kinda amazing. It's a rabbit hole in itself. But, I hope we never find I personally hope we never find out.

632
00:52:54.310 --> 00:52:56.890
I will say, even if we did find out today,

633
00:52:57.349 --> 00:52:58.730
that person has been

634
00:52:59.109 --> 00:53:02.010
effectively removed from all development in Bitcoin.

635
00:53:03.825 --> 00:53:08.245
So I'm just covering my bases. Like, if Satoshi turns out to be a complete asshole,

636
00:53:09.105 --> 00:53:10.885
like, don't hold that against Bitcoin.

637
00:53:11.345 --> 00:53:26.780
He hasn't been involved for a long long time. But you know it would be. Like, if that's a perfect and he doesn't have to be an asshole. Right? It's, like, then all of a sudden it becomes political. It's, like, 50% of the country thinks he's a horrible person. 50% of the country thinks he's a great person. It jades the whole project. Everything becomes,

638
00:53:27.640 --> 00:53:31.420
a popularity contest. So, hopefully, that that never happens.

639
00:53:32.545 --> 00:53:36.245
But anyway, general, thanks again for joining us. This has been absolutely,

640
00:53:37.425 --> 00:53:37.925
fantastic.

641
00:53:38.225 --> 00:53:38.785
I know,

642
00:53:39.265 --> 00:53:41.585
this is not your usual element. I see,

643
00:53:42.225 --> 00:53:44.965
someone in the comments. Who is it? Sypher Hoodlum

644
00:53:45.280 --> 00:53:50.900
said it's funny how last last week's episode of Citadel Dispatch was 15 prolific Bitcoin developers

645
00:53:51.200 --> 00:54:00.900
on, like, 4 mics with no camera. And they weren't, like, holding their mics and stuff. And then we have the attorney general the next week in a beautifully welded studio, perfect audio.

646
00:54:02.055 --> 00:54:05.355
That's still a dispatch for you freaks. But I I I think going forward,

647
00:54:05.895 --> 00:54:10.075
we have our new producer at the park here. Paul is here and and Pete from,

648
00:54:10.935 --> 00:54:11.435
Swan,

649
00:54:12.295 --> 00:54:12.795
graciously

650
00:54:13.494 --> 00:54:15.355
helped us set all this up.

651
00:54:16.029 --> 00:54:24.289
And I think, going forward, we're just gonna do higher production quality. I think I think the world needs it, and I think you freaks deserve it. So we're gonna keep that coming. And

652
00:54:24.910 --> 00:54:30.505
the Attorney General had the honor of being the first one on this setup. So Cool. Thank you. Thank you, sir.