Reviews

Rate Show

At last!!
This is the first time I’ve ever felt compelled to write review a podcast, and I’m doing it now because I need everyone to know how good this one is. It’s so good guys!! I majored in Film Studies at university and even though I did not pursue a career in the industry, I still dearly love to watch, think, and talk about movies. However, I’ve struggled to find a podcast about film that I really relate to and felt meaningful to me - until now. Sarah, Alex and their wonderful guests are the exact kind of people who I’d like to sit around and talk about movies with. I’ve burned my way through all the episodes on ones I’ve seen and am playing catch up as fast as I can with the others, but honestly I’ll just listen to them talk about movies I’ve never even seen. That’s how much I love this show.

you are good is good
super genuine, funny, and interesting, 10/10

Cinephiles Unite!
I absolutely adore the chemistry that these two have, and I’m so happy to have another show featuring Sarah Marshall. I find solace in these like-minded individuals, as I am also a 30-something myself. I really enjoy listening in on their conversations about various movies, and often will listen to the episode before and after I watch the movie being discussed. They offer refreshing perspectives and each time a new episode is released, it feels like Christmas every time. Keep up the great work y’all.

Joyful and illuminating show, from the siblings who replaced us
It hit me when I was listening to the episode on the Big Chill and they were saying, these were our parents, and I thought, no these were *our* parents. Of course, they would not recognize what they represent to us— the Gen X kids from the Breakfast Club—they were the babies that our aunts had—the ones who waited to have their kids until they had a degree, or the babies that our parents had after they found themselves and got remarried. The millennials were the babies that our friends at The Breakfast Club had to love and care for, while suppressing the jealousy they felt when their dads said some variation of, “This time I’m really going to get it right!” They were the babies from the custody cases I heard about from the perspective of their much older siblings and cousins— the babies who got so much more attention and so many more promises, but got betrayed in their own way. We were the ones that everyone wanted to forget when they started over with their new families, after they got their degrees— the ones the first batch of boomers had when they were in their early twenties, just before feminism took off. I love how these kids turned out— I understand why the Gen X’ers are bitter about being forgotten by their boomer parents and millennial siblings— but I’d rather listen to these two any day. You are good!

YAG
Another one of Sarah Marshall’s projects that has been getting me through the pandemic. Seriously though, You Are Good brings my blood pressure down and makes me feel so many ways. It’s warm, intelligent, thoughtful, and it’s quickly become my favorite movie podcast. A couple of movie suggestions I would like to bring to the table: 1.) All That Jazz. I watched it for the first time last night, and if that’s not about feelings then I don’t know what is. 2.) Hook. One of the more iconic movies from my childhood, a solid dad theme, and Robin Williams. It checks so many boxes. Adore you both and thank you for doing what you do. PS-I can’t stop thinking of Christian Slater as Theodore Laurence and I will never be the same.

Therapeutic. Sharp. Hilarious. I love it.
This feelings podcast about movie HITS! You do not need to see the movie to enjoy the chats. Sarah and Alex have the best chemistry, they always have incredible guests who have their own great shows/content so this is also a great space to find new stuff! The topics discussed are always relevant and I can always feel the emotions resonating through the podcast and into my soul. Sarah and Alex have a fun way of putting even the most depressing realities, and since we live in one of those, it’s great to hear a fun description of it. The pod also has dope original music some of the times! They’ll be releasing some of those songs soon too! Not to mention the episode-inspired playlists released with each new episode. Overall the production of the podcast is tight and calming - an awesome combo. Shout out to Carolyn. I’d listen to these humans talk about anything.

Pump Up The Volume
HA! — I was a junior at Saugus High School, in Santa Clarita, CA, when Pump Up The Volume was filmed. I was an extra in the film (we got excused from class so it was totally worth it despite laboring for long hours for free), and at the time, I wrote for the school newspaper and got to interview Christian Slater in his trailer. Oh my heart! My life was forever changed! In the evenings we loitered on campus and hung out with Seth Green and Ahmet Zappa between their scenes. They were the nicest guys and incredibly down to earth. It was a delight to revisit this experience, long pushed to the deepest depths of my mind, and to hear your in-depth analyses of the film. Now I feel the need to watch it again. And yes, the soundtrack is amazing and the highlight is Everybody Knows, by Leonard Cohen. Thanks a ton!

You had me at Heavyweight…
Sarah Marshall can do no wrong. The content is fun, informative and nostalgic; my inner child is screaming.

Warm, smart friends talking about movies
This is a wonderful podcast. The hosts are funny and insightful. The tone will change somewhat based on the guest, which is actually nice - the hosts seem to really enjoy their guests. They’re generous with the movies they review and I’m looking forward to revisiting some of the movies covered and watching others for the first time.

Newest obsession ✊🏿✊🏿
I love you guys! PLEASE REVIEW THE FILM SCHOOL TIES WITH BRENDAN FRASER!!

Suggestion
Y’all need to review the Emperor’s Club. It was made for your show. There are so many daddies in it.

💜
Sarah Marshall is so heartwarming.

Internet Friends
Getting to engage in this show throughout the pandemic has been such a highlight of an exhausting experience. Every time I hear Sarah and Alex greet each other I feel like I just walked into a room with old friends. Being able to engage with them on social media and feel like I’m apart of something that helps me grow and reflect on ways to be better and good is also something this show has brought to my life. I have watched a lot of movies I might not have thought about, I’ve laughed out loud running down the street and I have made some pretty awesome internet friends through You Are Good. Thanks for existing folks!

Love this show
My better half (read wife) introduced me to this show because she loves me and knows I am a cinephile and listen to podcasts. Thank you for the wonderful discussions and new and enlightening perspective on current and classic films. Always a pleasure and joy listening to the hosts and their guests select from a new title each week (still trying to convince My Better Half to give the Texas Chain Saw Massacre episode a listen, I’ll keep trying my best). Thank you again. Xoxo

Get your soul touched
I do jigsaw puzzles late into the quiet night. The stars are benign, the lamps are soft and the podcasts —this podcast— is soul touching. Listen.

If you want to laugh and occasionally cry happy tears
This podcast is amazing!! I've listened since it was "why are dads" and even in its beta version it was amazing. The movies they pick, the guests, the humor, it has it all. Sarah's intro to the most recent episode mentions how this podcast got her though the pandemic, I 💯 agree. Laughing with this group of people I have never met, has made me feel less isolated in this ridiculous reality we have and gave me something to mark the weeks. This podcast is my favorite even though I follow all of the extended YAG family. I look forward to Halloween week (or month if Sarah wants it to be) last years did not disappoint!! You are good!!! 🙌

Comforting Podcast
I really enjoy this podcast. Sarah is so insightful and I love her unique analysis of movies. Sarah and Alex are a great combination for podcast about movies and feelings. Also the best episodes are the ones with guest Aubrey Gordon! Also I really like the new name. Much more welcoming. 🥰

The best
Podcast ever!!

I love this podcast
You are good (and when was why are dads) is the such a calming podcast. It makes me feel so relaxed and makes me smile :)

More Sarah Marshall!!
I love listening to Sarah Marshall and now I love listening to Alex Steed too. Wanna hear smart, empathetic people talk about movies you may or may not have seen? This is the podcast for you.

The podcast that I didn’t know I needed in my life
A movie podcast about feelings?? Yes please! I don’t really watch movies but there’s something about so comforting about these discussions

I love this podcast.
I have so many feelings… all of them are filled with joy when I listen to these two talk.

Lovely
Alex and Sarah always have very thoughtful insights and they deliver them with such good humor. This podcast feels like such a safe space, I look forward to new episodes of Y.A.G. more than any other pod. Can’t recommend enough.

Batman Returns episode prompted 5 star review
Why are so many movie podcasts so bad? This one is good! It gave me the Batman Returns conversation I’ve been waiting on my whole life.

Love
I’m not even a movie person but this podcast makes you love the weekly content. It gives me wa rm fuzzies even when they are critiquing content because the hosts are so kind & deep. If you want to explore your emotions and outlook on the world thru the lens of lighthearted movies, please relax to this podcast!

this is my favorite podcast
Sarah and Alex have lovely chemistry. I could hear them talk about movies all day, even about ones I haven't seen. Their conversations are genuine and I always leave each episode feeling good.

This podcast is so lovely
Sarah and Alex are truly the best. I love their sweet, spicy, and everything-in-between takes on films. Whether I’ve seen/heard of the movie or not, I have a blast. They have even encouraged me thru their conversations to see movies I would have never considered watching before, that always turn out to be amazing. Their guests are also great! You can’t go wrong having a listen. Check it out :)

Love this!!
I just love this podcast. Even episodes on movies I haven’t seen are interesting and entertaining.

It’s almost there
I’ve been listening to this podcast on and off from the beginning of it. I, like many others, was led over by You’re Wrong About. I almost completely enjoy this podcast. However, the editing really throws me off. The intro is hugely long, there are random musical interludes that last a weirdly long time, and I’ll be really into the conversation and there are just a lot of random cuts. I enjoy the show and the way the conversation feels so casual. However, the editing is really disjointed and can make it kind of irritating.

Like a long warm hug for your brain
If you want a podcast that feels like a long, warm hug, this is the podcast for you. I turn it on whenever I need a pick-me-up. Alex and Sarah have the uncanny ability to communicate in a way that feels extremely specific to their friendship but is also open enough for a stranger to drop in and join the chat, like you’re at a party and you sit down by some kids talking about movies because you don’t know anyone else and you can’t resign yourself to petting the dog all evening. It’s kind, it’s welcoming, it’s nerdy, and you might spend all night holding court with them to drown out the chaos happening all around you. Five out of five stars.