Episodes

May 30, 2024

Just Like My Brothers: Lloyd Crosbie

Lloyd Crosbie grew up idolizing his two older brothers. They taught him dysfunction and violence. When Lloyd's brothers were locked up on murder related charges, he decided that he needed to be just like them and wanted to b…
May 23, 2024

Camp Keller: Peter Keller

Usually when we make plans for the future, they include our loved ones. That was not the case for Peter Keller when he pursued his childhood dream of living in the woods. This selfish dirtbag convinced himself that killing h…
May 16, 2024

Mean Nadean: Lois Nadean Smith & James Gregory Smith

Most mothers would do everything possible to protect their child, but what Lois Nadean Smith did in 1982, was inexcusable and unwarranted. Lois had already earned herself the nickname 'Mean Nadean' and taught her son to foll…
May 9, 2024

Precious Secrets: Megan Huntsman

In 2012, Darren West and his family found something that they never expected while cleaning out their family garage; seven tiny boxes holding seven tiny bodies. With this discovery, Megan Huntsman's secrets were revealed. Th…
May 2, 2024

Smells Like Catfish: Thomas Montgomery

Thomas Montgomery was bored with his life at the age of 45. A loving wife, two children, and a steady job wasn't enough for him. One day Thomas decided to reinvent his younger self and became an 18-year-old marine sniper onl…
April 25, 2024

Agendas, Angles and Twinkies: Daniel James White

In 1978, when Dan White took office, the political arena in San Francisco wasn't just cut-throat, it was outright murderous. The motives behind the assassinations of Harvey Milk and George Moscone were veiled under many agen…
April 18, 2024

Straight 'A' Killer: Michael Hernandez

Michael Hernandez was a gifted student who attended Southwood Middle School in Palmetto Bay in Miami-Dade County. By the time Michael turned fourteen, he went from a sweet and caring kid, to a boy obsessed with murder and vi…
April 11, 2024

Lies, Gossip, and Betrayal: Sheila Davalloo

In 2003, Sheila Davalloo tried to murder her husband, Paul Christos, while playing an erotic game. He lived through the attack only to find out the true depth of her evil betrayal. Unknown to everyone, this obsessed dirtbag …
April 4, 2024

Abuse of Power: Drew Peterson

Drew Peterson was a serial groom and massive womanizer. Although he continues to plead his innocence, Drew used his position in the Bolingbrook Police Department to his advantage. This dirtbag threatened the women in his lif…
March 28, 2024

Resurrected Truth: John Bernard Feit

The truth about the 1960 Easter murder of Irene Garza was discovered shortly after her body was found, but was then buried by the most unlikely people. It would take 57 years to resurrect it again, and hold the dirtbag who c…
March 21, 2024

Green Eyed Monster: Bernadette Protti

How far would you go to fit in or protect your image? Bernadette Protti became hyper fixated on her classmate, Kirsten Costas. To Bernadette, Kirsten had everything she wanted and Bernadette was all consumed with using Kirst…
March 14, 2024

Hidden Secrets: Patrick Quirke

In 2019, Ireland's longest running murder trial, for the murder of Bobby Ryan, took center stage as the media reported on the hidden secrets of a small farming community. At the center of the scandal was a sordid love affair…
March 7, 2024

Six Times a Bride: Betty Lou Beets

Betty Lou Beets has been referred to as Texas' Black Widow. She had a reputation of chewing up men and spitting them out. Many believe that due to the abuse she endured during her childhood, as well as at the hands of some o…
Feb. 29, 2024

All American Nightmare: Lance Butterfield

When one father's dream of becoming an all American football star are dashed, he see's redemption in the lives of his children. Bill Butterfield's drive to see his son, Lance, succeed on the football field becomes an obsessi…
Feb. 22, 2024

Earthquake Murders: Herbert Mullin

What lengths would you go to in order to protect the place where you live? Herbert Mullin decided in the 1970s that he had to sacrifice the lives of others in order to prevent the State of California from being destroyed by …
Feb. 15, 2024

25 Cromwell Street: Fred & Rosemary West

For over two decades, 25 Cromwell Street hid the secrets of Fred and Rosemary 'Rose' West. The murderous duo raped, tortured, and murdered at least a dozen young British girls between 1967 and 1987 in Gloucestershire. Even t…
Feb. 14, 2024

Broken Hearts Collaboration: Bonus Episode

Every true crime enthusiast knows that love can sometimes take a dark turn, leading to unimaginable consequences. Join us as we explore cases where love went horribly wrong. We have teamed up with six of our podcast friends …
Feb. 8, 2024

Turmoil in Mission Hill: Charles Stuart

On October 23, 1989, a 911 call was placed from the Mission Hill area in Boston. Charles Stuart and his pregnant wife, Carol, had been shot while on their way home from a birthing class. Charles told the police that a black …
Feb. 1, 2024

Worth of a Friendship: Ashley McArthur

How much value do you attach to your friendships? The dirtbag, Ashley McArthur, proved that she didn't assign a great deal of worth to her friendships when she murdered her friend, Taylor Wright, in Pensacola, Florida in 201…
Jan. 25, 2024

Victims or Villans?: Lyle & Erik Menéndez

Lyle and Erik Menéndez were American brothers who brutally took the lives of their parents, José and Kitty Menendez, in 1996. The boys quickly began spending their multi million-dollar inheritance, causing suspicion to rise.…
Jan. 18, 2024

Dastardly Duo: Carl Hall & Bonnie Heady

In 1953, the Greenlease family was enjoying a life of luxury and success, never guessing that they were at the center of two drunken dirtbags' deadly obsession. In an attempt to pull off the largest ransom at the time, Carl …
Jan. 11, 2024

Betrayed by Family: Stanley Dishon

Stanley Dishon was a massive dirtbag who spent years abusing the children in his extended family. Fueled by jealousy and the fear of getting caught, Stanley decided to kidnap, torture, and ultimately murder his 17-year-old …
Jan. 4, 2024

Chances and Choices: Adam Lawson

On the morning of March 23, 2017, Adam Lawson chose to enter the Liles' Panorama Park home in Jacksonville to steal their valuables. When he found Deborah Liles there alone, he made the dirtbag decision to end her life. Duri…
Dec. 28, 2023

Q & A With Christie & Melissa

Join us for a special episode where you asked the questions and we gave the answers. We will be discussing everything from which dirtbags we hate the most to how we got started on this wild adventure of podcasting! As always…