Reviews

Rate Show

Love this show
Alex and Sarah have great chemistry and are so thoughtful and sensitive in their commentary. 10/10

Stand By Me
Very entertaining! I love your visits to the Stephen Kingdom. Can Dolores Claiborne be far behind?!?!? When I read The Body in my chubby youth, I never considered that King was being particularly unkind to fat people, more that he was showing what fat kids had to experience, not necessarily with compassion, per se, but at least not avoiding it. Your discussion will make me examine his stuff more closely on re-reads to see if I agree. I alway appreciate a new perspective from the feelings reviews! Thank you! Alex, you are our Chris.

You are good superman episode
Superfun superman podcast. Fangirl jeane is one of my faves!

SO FREAKING DELIGHTFUL!!!
A “feelings podcast about movie“” sounds like it might be, I don’t know, self indulgent? Squirmy? THIS AIN’T THAT, FOLKS This is two smart, perspicacious, thoughtful, generous, sharp eyed and huge hearted folks, who are frequently joined by guests who are all that plus bring their own expertise and wisdom and joy to table. They talk about movies and use them as a lens to talk about everything. The episode that won my fealty forever was the one on Thor: Ragnarok with Fangirl Jeanne. I clicked on it because I like that movie and I already knew I loved Sarah Marshall (from the also excellent and unmi’sable You’re Wrong About). Well, let me tell you, Jeanne’s read on Thor, a super hero movie with two, cis-het, white male leads, from her perspective as an indigenous, bi-racial, queer woman about a movie made by a bi-racial, indigenous, half Jewish film maker as a mediation on diaspora and otherness BLEW MY MIND!! Check it out, you won’t be sorry!

Super good podcast! With one caveat.
Love Sarah Marshall and Alex Steed, they regularly have great guests who I haven’t necessarily heard of and they are all passionate about the films they have come to talk about and I love that. However Alex Steeds preamble before the episode begins is horrifically long. This weeks episode (George of the Jungle) took 10full minutes before it got started and that is not very engaging and I usually just skip that part anyway.

Pretty poggers
I think the podcast is good, just not something I’m into. I found that the intro was a little long, but that’s just my opinion. Love the movie selection, keep it up.

tbh my favorite podcast
the best podcast out there, so so so so so so so so so so so good thank you for doing an ep on “that thing you do!” love ya’ll

This is Awesome
Haha I couldn’t think there was a better podcast for me. I love talking about movies but my friends don’t :)

Feels like friends
Though I did not grow up with the same nostalgia and childhood movies, this podcast has pointed me to some truly great films. But more importantly, listening feels like hanging out with friends.

Kindness in a pod
This podcast has brought me so much joy from the very beginning. Two hilarious, insightful friends who clearly adore and respect the crap out of each other talking about movies? This is my happy place. Whether it’s a film I grew up with, or one I’ve never seen (or sometimes, like with the horror picks, I fully never intend to see), I never miss an episode. Watching these films after listening enriches the experience so much. Thank you for bringing conversations full of nuance, kindness, and generous assumptions to the world. You make it a better place, and YOU, too, are good!!

Equally emotionally intelligent and the regular kind
I recommend this podcast to absolutely everyone I know: so smart and kind and funny. An honest-to-god bright spot in my week. And, like, worth several sessions of therapy if that’s a draw to any recovering addicts out there. Thanks for creating magic you guys!!

Finally
This is the first review I’ve ever left for a podcast. But after this weeks episode about “Ratatouille” I just had to leave a review. For one specific reason. And that’s when you all referenced that Cheetohs commercial! I too have heard it everyday for the last few months. I get worried when I don’t hear the commercial. Lol. Love the podcast. Keep up the great work. I’d love to hear you guys comment on Interstellar. :-)

Gotta love Sarah + Alex
I’ve been listening to this podcast from the very beginning and have been listening to You’re Wrong About podcast for 3 years now. I look forward to listening to Alex and Sarah every week even if I’m not familiar with the movie. Love y’all! Can’t wait for future episodes.

Love this.
This show brings lots of joy along with specific and precise insights. Super recommend.

Chats with friends
Hanging out with Sarah and Alex is so comforting. I spent years bring snobbish about movies and they have given me permission to just like what I like. I love the guests and they always make me want to see the movie they talk about. I love this podcast so much.

Where wolf? There wolf! There castle!
This podcast is like wrapping your brain in a warm blanket - so comforting, even when they talk about tough topics. I always feel better after listening, and usually watch/rewatch the movie of the week because their love for it is contagious! Would rate all the stars in the sky if I could :)

Love This Podcast
I love listening to them talk about movies. It makes me feel like I’m hanging out with old friends. I even love the episodes about movies I haven’t seen. I am also a Patreon member and the bonus episodes are just as amazing (see: episode about grief) I hope this one goes on forever.

One of My Favorites
This is a podcast about movies but it is actually a podcast about being a human with feelings. The hosts and guests are so open and honest about their lives and emotions. I appreciate that they never talk about a movie as a “guilty pleasure,” that a movie like Newsies can be just as important as a movie like Goodfellas. What’s important is how we the audience respond, what we bring from our own lives to the experience of watching the movie. I watch movies in a much more authentic and open way after listening to this podcast. Thanks so much!

Erin
One of my favorite pods. Alex and Sarah have such great chemistry, and they’re both so genuinely warm and funny. Listening to their show is like hanging out and talking movies with my delightfully quirky imaginary friends.

Feel good
Love this podcast, Sarah Marshall is fantastic and always makes me laugh. There’s a conversational quality that makes you feel like you’re just hanging with some friends discussing movies.

You are enjoying this already
You are laughing at a horror movie. You are listening to curated (and some created) music by the woman that makes this sound so great. You are enjoying talks about grief, even when you just watched a horror movie. You are learning about the AIDS crisis through HBO projects. You are enjoying life a little more, because this gang makes you see the good in it all.

Fantastic!
I love the balance that Alex and Sarah have between humor and real deep sensitivity - this podcast is one of my favorites!

Always dependably solidly terrific
Nice, funny, insightful people talking about movies. One of my faves. Always delivers, whether I’ve seen the film or not.

Just lovely
I wasn’t sure to what to expect from another podcast about movies, but this is just lovely. When they talk about movies I’ve seen and loved, it’s like chatting with friends. When they talk about movies I haven’t seen, it’s better than actually watching the movie itself! Love them both, great work.

Love the Podcast…
…And I’d follow Sarah Marshall anywhere 🥰 If you ever have merch please announce it ASAP. A mug or t-shirt of your pod art would sooth my soul 😌

Amazingly Uplifting
I love this podcast. The reverence they show each movie is truly amazing and gives me faith in the goodness of humanity. They analyze each story with a human lens, not purely technical and psychological (though they do touch on those). It’s so real, and really beautiful. PS: Sarah and Alex, please do Interstellar! It’s got a Dad, a Daddy, and so much more!

No, I’m not exaggerating.
This podcast saved my life during some of the most harrowing MH/su*cidal incidents of my life, got me through the worst of pandemic times, and always avails itself to me as a balm for the soul in an ever-increasingly hostile, insensitive world. That should be quite enough to recommend it. And to think, I was put off by the old title “Why Are Dads” and almost didn’t give it a chance.

Everything Sarah Marshall touches is gold
You’re Wrong About is great, this show is great, Alex is great, the guests are great, I wish I had better adjectives but I’m a mom who listens to this show before bed and I’m tired. Just listen with me, you won’t be disappointed.

Enough with the intros already please
They are just too long guys

There’s this thing that happens…
In life where I’m trying to explain something, and I pull words from You Are Good. And when I go to reference it I realize that this quote that feels as if it is from yesterday is actually from a year or more ago. Alex and Sarah’s ability to pull meaning (and maybe more importantly feelings) from the art that is movies is unparalleled.