Reviews

Rate Show

AMAZING work!
Thank you for putting a spotlight on this case. This is an egregious miscarriage of justice. Leo Schofield deserves justice for himself, and for Michelle. The way this case has been handled is disgusting from top to bottom. I don’t want to feel bad for Jeremy Scott, but when Victoria Avalon questioned him it brought tears to my eyes. No human deserves to be talked to that way. FREE LEO SCHOFIELD!!!

Must listen
I was born and raised in Polk County. I know every location mentioned, but I have never heard this tragic story. This is an excellent podcast and I couldn’t stop listening. #justiceforleo

Emotionally powerful
This is not simply another murder “who done it” crime podcast. It is the story of two men — two men who both seeking justice and redemption in their own ways. I am so appreciative as a listener and a human being that the tellers let us see the humanity behind these two men, and I appreciate Leo … and Jeremy…sharing their stories with all of us. I have not been this emotionally impacted by another podcast in a very long time. Worth every minute spent listening.

Best Podcast!
Hard to put into words how powerful this podcast is. We should all be telling Leo’s story - and Gilbert King just could not have done a more phenomenal job. Wishing and hoping that justice for Leo and Michelle will come some day. Make this right, Florida!

Very well done
This podcast was wonderful to listen to. The audio is perfect. The investigation is superbly done. It’s always nice to hear interviews with the subjects. I really look forward to hearing more from this team. Many Thanks for the great work. ( and not a lot of ads ).

Totally worth your time
Riveting, perfectly-paced podcast. Praying for an update.

Very well done!
One of the best produced podcasts I’ve listened to in a long while.

One of the best podcasts
This is story is absolutely riveting. Incredibly well told. A true masterpiece.

One of the best
I listen to many true crime podcasts. This is by far in my top 5.

True Crime Podcast top 5
This podcast is well done and The story is absolutely interesting. my heart breaks for Leo and his family. It is upsetting with all the evidence and the confession that Florida will not do the right thing

Fantastic Podcast
This is an incredibly heartbreaking and complicated story and this podcast does an amazing job telling the story. Investigative journalism at its finest, excellent sound production. The music is also incredible- bravo Leo. Florida is trash and I really hope Leo gets justice.

Absolutely incredible!!!
This is one of the best true crime/investigative journalism podcasts out there!!! Kudos for sharing this important story!! Justice for Leo!!

Incredible
Thank you for sharing this story. I’m not a praying kind of person but I send my best hopes to all involved. Hopeful for a resolution to this story for the sake of Leo, Michelle, family, and for Jeremy. And also…F*** Florida.

Absolutely Astounding!
I am beyond impressed with this podcast! Such an amazing and articulate narrator/author/investigator who’s fight for the truth and justice is so inspirational!! It is good knowing that when the system fails you (not saying they always get it wrong but it’s tough for people in authoritative positions to admit when an error was made) that someone…anyone is in your corner seeking the answers. Hoping and praying my state of FL sees the light and frees Leo!! Maybe send this podcast to Ron DeSantis!? He is amazing and for sure would listen!!

Great listen!
I enjoyed this podcast, it was one I didn’t want to stop listening to. The story is heartbreaking on all sides

Great job on the podcast
One of the best I’ve listened to. Also great voice, very easy listening!

Definition of a broken system
This is an excellent podcast. The case highlights a sad fact: the people behind bars aren’t always all bad, and the people behind the law aren’t always all good. I will pray Mr. Schofield is released and fully exonerated. And I will pray Mr. Scott finds peace with the trauma of his childhood and impact of the things he has done.

Amazing
I spend a lot of my time in the car driving listening to podcasts. This podcast by far is one of the best I’ve heard hopefully the state of Florida sees it the right way and frees this man.

Absolutely Incredible
I pray this podcast will grow to become as big and as life changing as the podcasts that highlighted the cases against Adnan Syed and Curtis Flowers. THIS IS A MUST LISTEN.

🤯 insane good
An amazingly produced podcast with twists and turns that will leave your jaw open.

The best podcast I have ever heard.
The story here is so horrific and sad that it’s almost unbelievable. But told so beautifully. Please listen.

Highly recommend
The story is great but it also hurts your heart another wrongful conviction with dirty sheriffs from Florida dirty prosecutors and the review boards sit in judgment of a man wrongfully convicted with no physical proof.Everyone responsible for preventing this case to be heard again should be tarred and feathered wait until their time comes and they are judged by GodFor this crime

In My Top 5
I’ve listened to a lot of True Crime podcasts, and this is definitely one of the best. It is engaging and well told and does a great job honoring the victim and representing everyone involved. Greatly helped by the hosts’ investment in the case, you feel the emotions alongside them - hope, anger, sadness. Thank you for shining a light on this case!

Binge listen
This podcast is so good. Once I started listening, I couldn’t stop and actively wait for the new episodes to release. Such great investigating and reporting that keeps the listener engaged. Highly recommend!

listen. listen, listen, listen.
This story is so important. It is devastating & enraging & awful to hear Leo’s story (a story that’s exceptionally researched, written, & told by Gilbert & Kelsey). I walked away with the burning desire to DO SOMETHING. ANYTHING. to help change the script here. It’s so critical that this podcast gets the exposure required to make a difference in this case. Really, do listen.

A Justice system far beyond broken!
This podcast is something I can’t even describe with words! It’s kept me up at night, I’ve shed many of tears for not only Leo but Jeremy & all involved. A turned stomach of knots with a sickness thinking about the realization of our broken Justice system & corruption beyond anything anyone could even imagine. Egregious behavior from the ones at the very top that hold the life of one’s in the palm of their hands.

A must listen!
I’ve listened to many podcasts and this is a must! Wrongful conviction and corruption with the police and DA office. Heartbreaking but I’m so glad this story is told.

This show Has Layers!
It begins as a simple story about a man in jail for killing his wife, and the man who actually did it. And for many true crime podcasts that would be the whole story, but this podcast is about so many things, young love, unlikely romances, tenacious reporting, empathy, or at least understanding for the real murderer. It shows what damage is wrought when the justice system can’t get it right by either not convicting a dangerous person before he goes on to kill again or by convicting someone of killing somebody they loved and the pain that causes. All the characters are really interesting too. I’m in to it.

Very well done!
A great, sad story that was told very well. I hope Leo gets the justice I believe he deserves.

Masterful story telling
I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts, and this may be the best I have ever encountered. Not only was the story well told, but the level of humanity brought to such a sad, horrible story is commendable. I sat in my car, with tears streaming down my cheeks as this wrapped the last episode. This is a complex situation and I really appreciate that the due diligence was done and instead of demonizing and simplifying the people and details the listeners were able to really feel the situation and all those involved. Well done.